I love the way he acts all mature. That's what pulled me back in.
But there's an invisible wall between us. I can feel it every time he replies.
He's cautious. Careful. Like he's following a manual.
Last night, I couldn't take it anymore.
"Can I ask you something?" I typed. "Why do you just disappear?"
He was online. Then offline. Then online again.
"Sorry, I was busy," he said.
"You said that last time too," I said. "I told you it bothers me when you just vanish. It feels like my words don't get through to you at all."
Silence for a minute. Then the three dots.
"Can I be honest?" he said.
"Please."
"My ex... she hated clingy guys. She hated when I would message too much or ask where she was. So I learned to hold back. To be careful. To not be too much."
My chest dropped. Because his ex — she's the girl after me.
"Wait," I said. "So you're being careful with me... because of her?"
"I guess I'm just used to it," he said. "I'm adjusting. I don't want to mess this up again."
I stared at that message.
"But Josh," I whispered, even though he couldn't hear me, "I _like_ clingy."
"What?" he replied.
"Nothing," I typed. "I like when a guy craves me. When he's a little possessive. A little controlling. I like a leader, not someone who only moves when I tell him to. I like someone who wants me too much, not someone who is scared to want me at all."
He didn't reply right away.
"I can try to be more like that," he said finally.
And that's when I understood.
He may give me his time now. His attention. His late-night flirting.
But he isn't mine. Not before, not now, and probably not ever.
Because his default was built on her. And I am a fool for leaving something good, just to fall back into the abyss of wanting someone from my past who never saw my value.
He didn't see it then.
He doesn't see it now.
And he probably never will.
==============================
The Fear
________________________
After that night, we kept talking. He tried harder. He really did.
"Good morning," he'd text first now.
"Did you eat already?"
"Where are you?"
The clingy things I said I wanted. But it felt... rehearsed. Like he was reading from a script she made him memorize.
One night, he left me on delivered for 6 hours.
I spiraled.
"Are you with her?" I typed, then deleted it.
"Are you busy?" I sent instead.
"No, sorry, just tired," he replied.
But my mind was already there.
"Josh, can I tell you something stupid?" I said on call that night.
"What is it?"
"I'm scared," I whispered. "I'm scared that one day she'll come back."
He went quiet.
"Why would you think that?"
"Because you still love her default," I said, my voice shaking. "You still move like a man who is afraid to lose her. Not a man who is afraid to lose me. And what if she texts you tomorrow? What if she says she misses you? Would you go careful with her too? Or would you run?"
"Celine, don't do this..."
"No, answer me. If she comes back, what happens to me? To us? What am I then? Just the girl before her again?"
He sighed. That heavy, mature sigh I used to love.
"She's not coming back. We're done."
"But you were done with me once too," I said. "And look, we're here again. People come back, Josh. Especially when someone left them first."
"So you're saying I still love her?"
"I'm saying I'm scared you never stopped building your life around not losing her. And I'm just living in the house she designed."
There was a long pause.
"I don't know how to prove to you that I'm here now," he said.
And I didn't know how to tell him that "here now" was never the problem.
The problem was I knew — deep down — that if she ever knocked, the wall I felt between us would finally make sense.
It was never built to keep me out.
It was built to keep a space open for her to come back in.
The end