He Wanted Her to Open Up, Just Not Like That.
She was seventeen when she met him.
It started like most online conversations do. A few messages, some curiosity, random conversations that slowly became a part of her everyday routine. He was twenty-two. There was an age difference, but at first, she didn't think much about it. She was simply interested in knowing someone new, someone she could talk to without having to think too much about what to say.
She was a cheerful girl, at least on the surface. She joked around, said ridiculous things sometimes, laughed at things that weren't even funny, and occasionally spoke without thinking.
But there was another side of her that very few people knew.
She was an overthinker. Someone who could spend hours thinking about a conversation that had lasted only a few minutes. Someone who had a habit of keeping things to herself, not because she didn't want to be understood, but because she never really knew how to explain what was happening inside her.
Expressing feelings was never easy for her.
And then there was him.
He seemed to know exactly what he liked and what he didn't. He was very particular about his boundaries, his expectations, his preferences, and the way people treated him.
If something disappointed him, he would say it.
If something hurt him, he would explain it.
If he found her behaviour disrespectful, she would hear about it.
Again and again.
She listened. Sometimes she agreed, sometimes she didn't, but she tried to understand him. She remembered the things he disliked and became more careful about how she behaved around him.
After all, she didn't want to hurt someone she genuinely enjoyed talking to.
But somewhere between all those conversations, she started noticing something.
He always had something to say about how she made him feel.
But what about how he made her feel?
She wasn't someone who could easily say, "That hurt me," or "I didn't like the way you spoke to me."
Most of the time, she would simply think about it, convince herself that perhaps she was overreacting, and move on.
Still, she tried.
She tried to share little things about herself. Her random thoughts, her silly jokes, her unusual opinions, even the things that didn't make much sense.
But somehow, whenever she did, there was always something wrong with it.
He didn't like that behaviour.
He didn't find that funny.
He didn't appreciate that way of speaking.
And slowly, she started questioning the very things that once came naturally to her.
The irony was that he often complained about how she never opened up to him.
"Why don't you share things with me?"
"You should be comfortable enough to tell me anything."
"I want you to open up."
She wondered how she was supposed to do that.
How could she explain the things she struggled to express when the little things she did manage to express were so often met with disapproval?
He wanted her to be more expressive, but only when her expressions made sense to him.
He wanted her to be comfortable, but sometimes made her conscious of being herself.
He wanted to know what was going on inside her mind, but didn't always seem willing to understand the way her mind worked.
And perhaps the most confusing part was that she never really knew how to explain this contradiction to him.
Because whenever she thought about bringing it up, another thought followed.
What if he finds this disrespectful too?
What if he thinks I'm blaming him?
What if he misunderstands what I'm trying to say?
So she remained quiet.
Not because she suddenly had nothing to say, but because she had started calculating whether saying it was worth the consequences.
She began to realise something.
There is a difference between someone wanting you to open up and someone making you feel safe enough to do so.
You cannot keep asking someone to show you their vulnerable side while repeatedly making them feel uncomfortable about their natural personality.
And being considerate of someone's feelings shouldn't mean constantly neglecting your own.
She wasn't asking him to agree with everything she said. She wasn't expecting him to find every joke funny or appreciate every little thing she did.
She just wanted the same consideration he expected from her.
Perhaps she wasn't the easiest person to understand. Perhaps she had her own flaws, her own communication problems, and her own habits that needed improvement.
But didn't he have those too?
Why was understanding always something she was supposed to offer, rather than something they were supposed to practise together?
And one day, she found herself wondering:
If I have to keep editing my personality to make someone comfortable, at what point do I stop being myself?
Maybe he genuinely wanted to know her.
But did he want to know her as she was, or only the version of her that he preferred?
She didn't have an answer.
All she knew was that she had entered that conversation wanting to be understood, and somewhere along the way, she had become afraid of being misunderstood.
And perhaps that was the saddest part of it all.
Have you ever wanted to open up to someone so badly, yet slowly found yourself becoming quieter around them? I'd genuinely love to know your perspective on this.