Chapter 4 Those Who Did Not Return

The unit moved before the sun had fully lifted itself from the horizon still damp with night dew. There was no trumpet call to mark their departure. No line of shared prayer, no brief speech promising victory or reward. None of the rituals usually used to give meaning to the violence ahead. They left like men sent to finish a task that could not be delayed, a task that had to be done before the air grew too hot and before the smell of blood became too heavy to breathe.

The horses walked at an even pace. The cart wheels creaked softly over ground that was still loose. Weapons were held without ceremony, without excessive inspection, without eyes lit by enthusiasm. There was no spirit. No displayed hatred. Only habit.

Alaric was at the front. Not because he held a higher rank than the others, but because of a pattern formed over years. He was often placed at the point most likely to meet danger first. Not out of heroic courage, but because he rarely hesitated and rarely asked questions. He moved quickly, carried out orders without needing adjustment.

This unit was small, no more than a dozen men. Some were veterans whose faces had long since lost expression. Others were new soldiers whose brightness had dimmed faster than it should have. They carried no great banner. No symbol of honor was raised. They had not been sent to take a city or hold territory. They had been sent to clear what remained.

And what remained was always more complicated than open battle.

The unit’s commander was named Guillaume, a man who rarely spoke more than necessary. Along the road he gave orders through brief hand motions, pointing directions, marking the map with a fingertip. He did not study each soldier’s face. He did not seek emotional ties. He watched only the objective.

Guillaume was not the kind of leader who forged loyalty with words or promises. He forged it through quiet fear and consistent punishment. There were no angry outbursts from him, but there was no loose forgiveness either. Everything was done according to command, or consequences came, clear and swift.

Their first destination was a small village set outside the main route. It was not recorded as strategic. No fortress, no armory, no grand military reason to notice it. Yet reports said that several wounded Crusaders had not returned to camp after the nearest city fell.

Witnesses claimed they had removed their insignia. Some had seen them change clothing, hide their armor, and attempt to blend with the locals. There were also reports of men hiding in ruined buildings, waiting for a time that never clarified, waiting for something they themselves might not have been able to name.

In official language, they were called deserters.

In the language of war, they were called a problem.

When the unit reached the edge of the village, Guillaume lifted a hand. The gesture was small, but it stopped the entire line. There was no charge. No shouted warning. They dismounted and entered with measured steps, as if the village itself were a living creature that could startle if handled too roughly.

Alaric studied the place. It looked quiet, but not empty. Doors were shut tight, but not locked in panic. Curtains shifted slightly behind windows, enough to show watching eyes. Footprints were visible in the ground still damp with morning dew, too fresh to ignore.

Alaric recognized the signs with an instinct honed over time. This was not a dead village. It was a village waiting.

They spread out in the formation they had agreed on without needing additional instruction. Two moved left, two right. Guillaume signaled for Alaric to follow him. They approached a low building at the far end of the village, an old storage shed half-collapsed, its walls cracked and its roof partially caved in.

The smell of dampness and animal waste mixed with something sharper. Old blood soaked into earth and wood. Guillaume signaled them to stop. He looked at Alaric with a stare that held no emotion at all.

“You go in first.”

It was not a request. It was an assignment.

Alaric nodded without a word. He stepped forward, shield raised, sword in his right hand. He pushed the wooden door that hung half off its hinges. It creaked softly before giving way. Inside, thin light slipped through holes in the roof. Dust drifted slowly in the air.

Alaric entered carefully, taking each corner in turn. In the back he saw a man sitting with his shoulder against the wall. The man’s leg was wrapped in a crude bandage. His face was pale, his eyes hollow.

He still wore Crusader clothing, though the insignia had been torn away in haste. He looked at Alaric with eyes no longer filled with anger or conviction. Only exhaustion and alertness remained.

“Stand,” Alaric said, voice flat.

The man did not move. “I cannot.”

Alaric stepped closer. He gave the man’s leg a light kick, not to punish, but to test if he was conscious and not pretending. The man winced, but did not cry out.

“You know the order,” Alaric said. “You have to come back.”

The man gave a quiet laugh, hoarse like stone dragged across dry ground. “Back to what.”

Alaric did not answer. He reached out, not to help, but to pull. The man seized Alaric’s wrist with a grip too strong for someone wounded.

“I have had enough,” the man said. “I do not want it anymore.”

The words were simple. No ideology. No scripture quoted. No grand reason. Only naked exhaustion.

Guillaume entered without unnecessary sound. He watched for a moment.

“Name.”

The man shook his head. “Not important.”

Guillaume gave a brief signal to another soldier. “Find the others.”

They found two more in another building. One tried to run and was struck by an arrow before he reached the edge of the village. The other surrendered without resistance. All three were brought to the village center and forced to kneel.

The locals watched from behind doors and narrow window gaps. No one spoke. They had learned that noise often invited attention they did not want.

Guillaume stood before the deserters.

“You broke your oath.”

One of them laughed bitterly. “That oath was made before we saw what we were doing.”

Guillaume turned to Alaric. “Your opinion.”

Alaric looked at the three men. He saw himself in an earlier form. Not because they were the same, but because they stood at a point he had avoided by killing questions inside his own head.

“They are still alive,” Alaric said. “They can still be used.”

Guillaume raised an eyebrow slightly. “Used for what.”

“Hard labor. Carrying. Cleaning. Information.”

Guillaume considered, then nodded. “This one.” He pointed to a single man. “Take him. The other two, no.”

The decision was carried out without further discussion. The two men were killed quickly. No drama. No speech. Blood sank into the soil, and the village fell silent again.

Alaric stood still. He did not close his eyes. He did not release a heavy breath. He only recorded the fact. Life and death were not decided by faith or sin, but by usefulness.

And the fact gave him nothing. No relief. No remorse. Only an empty space that was beginning to feel unfamiliar.

Alaric did not turn when the bodies fell. He did not need to see it to know the work was done. The dull sound of flesh meeting earth was enough. He shifted his gaze to the one man spared. The man trembled, not only from injury, but from understanding that his life had not been saved by value. It had been saved by cold chance.

They bound him and led him out of the village. He limped. His breath came short. Sometimes he looked at Alaric as if he wanted to say something, but the words never came.

“Thank you,” he said at last, barely audible.

Alaric did not answer. He walked ahead, securing the route. The words thank you sounded strange in his ear, not because he had never heard them, but because he knew they changed nothing. The man was alive now, but his life had changed hands. And those hands could let go at any time.

They moved to the next location without a long pause. Guillaume allowed no time for reflection. The unit shifted from one point to another like a tool designed to complete a list. Throughout the day, they found more deserters. The pattern was nearly always the same, though the details differed.

They were not ideological traitors. They did not speak of changing faith or collapsed loyalty. They were people who had run out of reasons to keep obeying. Some were wounded and could not walk far. Some had minds broken by too much death. Some only wanted to stop, without knowing what came after.

Some fought.

Some surrendered.

Some died where they stood.

Alaric executed orders with the same precision as before. His movements stayed efficient. His decisions stayed quick. Yet there was a small change he did not admit even to himself. He began to hear their sentences. He did not argue. He did not contradict. He only listened and stored the words away, like someone collecting fragments without knowing what they would be used for.

Toward late afternoon, they found a small group near a spring. The place was hidden by rocks and low brush. The water was clear and ran quietly, as if indifferent to everything around it. There, three Crusaders sat with a local man. They had removed nearly all signs of the army. There were no swords in their hands. No shields near them.

Guillaume signaled for the unit to surround them from a safe distance. When the soldiers appeared from behind the rocks, one Crusader rose slowly and lifted both hands. His face was dirty, his eyes red from lack of sleep.

“We will not fight,” he said, forcing calm into his voice.

Guillaume looked at him without expression. “You already fought by not returning.”

The man lowered his head. His shoulders fell. “We only wanted to live.”

Alaric felt something in his chest that he did not like. Something that moved too quickly to be called emotion, but too heavy to ignore. He stepped forward once.

“Why did you not return,” he asked.

One of them answered, voice trembling but clear. “Because we saw that the people we killed were no different from us.”

The sentence was not spoken dramatically. No tears. No long defense. Yet it struck harder than any battle cry. Guillaume lifted a hand, signaling his men to prepare.

Alaric spoke fast, before the signal became action. “They are unarmed.”

Guillaume looked at him. “And.”

“They are not dangerous now,” Alaric continued.

Guillaume moved closer. His voice dropped, meant for Alaric alone. “Our task is not to judge danger now. Our task is to prevent an example.”

The word returned again.

Example.

Not justice.

Not truth.

Only prevention.

The decision was made without counsel. Two Crusaders were killed where they sat. Quick and clean. The third was spared, not from mercy, but because he knew the water routes and the location of food stores not yet recorded.

The local man was released. He walked away without looking back, his pace quick, as if afraid the decision might change. Alaric watched the local man’s back longer than he should have. He did not know why his gaze followed the steps until they vanished behind the rocks. He only knew something felt left behind with that man.

Night fell when they returned to camp. Fires were lit. Reports were given in flat voices. Guillaume recorded the results in neat writing, as if he were not writing about human beings, but about numbers and goods.

Alaric sat farther from the fire. He cleaned his sword again, though it was barely stained. The motion felt different. No longer calming. Only a way to fill time so his thoughts would not move where he did not want them to go.

Etienne approached and sat with hesitation.

“You did not speak much today.”

Alaric did not turn. “There is nothing to speak about.”

Etienne was quiet for a moment. Firelight flickered across his face. “I saw them. The ones who did not return.”

“Yes.”

“They were like us,” Etienne said softly.

Alaric stopped rubbing the blade. He looked at Etienne.

“They were like us who stopped,” Etienne swallowed. “Was it wrong.”

The question hung in the night air. Alaric knew the official answer. He knew the expected answer. He knew what sentence should leave his mouth to keep the order clean. But tonight, those answers felt hollow.

“Right or wrong is not our concern,” Alaric said at last. “What is our concern is what comes after.”

Etienne lowered his head. “And what comes after.”

Alaric looked into the fire. Fire was always honest. It burned anything without choosing.

“After, history decides.”

Etienne did not ask again.

That night, Alaric did not sleep at once. He walked away from camp carrying a water sack. He stopped in a darker, quieter place, far from voices and the crackle of burning wood. There, he took out a piece of black cloth he kept inside his clothing. It was worn at the edges. He stared at it a long time without touching it.

He did not know who the woman was. He did not know where she had gone. He only knew that since that day, since that brief encounter without even a long conversation, the world was no longer divided entirely into command and execution.

He put the cloth away again.

In the distance, the adhan drifted through the air, quiet and far. The words were unclear, but the rhythm reached where he stood. The sound did not force. It did not demand. It simply existed.

Alaric did not cover his ears. He did not pray. He only stood, letting the sound pass over him like wind against skin without asking permission.

For the first time, he understood that a deserter was not only a man who left the line. A deserter was anyone who began to hear something beyond orders. And that night, between a small fire and a voice he did not understand, Alaric realized something that tightened his chest.

He had not deserted.

But he was not fully returned either.

Morning came without celebration. The sun rose slowly over the camp, lighting ground trampled by too many boots and too many decisions. Nothing in the world around them showed that the night before had carried change. The fires had died. Cold ash remained where wood had burned. Soldiers rose as usual, washed, put on armor, checked weapons.

Routine continued.

Alaric stood slightly apart, pouring water over his hands and washing his face with efficient movements. No nightmare had chased him that night. No voices, no shadows. Yet something lingered in his chest, a small weight not heavy enough to be called a wound, but real enough to change the breath.

He studied his hands. The same hands that had pulled, shoved, and killed. Nothing had changed physically. No tremor. No mark. Yet he knew something had shifted, and he did not know exactly when it happened.

Guillaume gave the morning orders in the same tone as always. A new route to check. Reports of small movement in territory not fully controlled. No pause for questions. No room for hesitation.

Alaric listened as he always had. He noted paths, distances, likely obstacles. But beneath it all, another layer had begun to work. A layer that did not measure effectiveness, but meaning. And it disturbed him.

They moved again. This time they found no resistance. No deserters. No village waiting in silence. Only ruins and the remains of life that had moved elsewhere. Yet the emptiness made his mind louder.

Alaric began to notice small things he would once have ignored. The way Guillaume gave orders without naming people, only positions and outcomes. The way soldiers spoke of death the way one spoke of weather. The way the word oath was repeated without ever being touched by meaning.

Oath. The word rose again in his mind.

He remembered the faces they had found. Those who did not return. Not one of them spoke of breaking an oath. They spoke of exhaustion. Of not being able. Of stopping.

Stopping. Not resisting.

For the first time, Alaric let the question exist without crushing it immediately. Had the oath been made to erase human limits, or to shape them. And if an oath demanded what could no longer be given, was breaking it sin, or consequence.

He disliked the direction of his own thoughts. He knew questions like that were dangerous, not because of their answers, but because of their existence.

At midday, the unit stopped briefly near a small stream, not a spring, only a narrow flow enough to fill their water sacks. A local child stood some distance away, watching them with wary eyes. He did not run. He did not come closer.

Alaric watched him. The child was thin. His clothes hung too large. One hand clenched something, perhaps a stone or a piece of wood. Alaric did not know if it was a weapon.

He only knew the child was preparing.

For what, Alaric did not know.

When Guillaume noticed the child, he gave a quick signal for one soldier to chase him off. The soldier stepped forward and shouted at the child to leave. The child ran. No blood. No tragedy. No grand event. Yet Alaric recorded something. The child did not run because of the shout. He ran because he had done it before.

Night fell again. Camp grew quiet. Fires were lit again. Conversation stayed short, tired, meaningless. Alaric sat alone longer than usual. He did not clean his sword that night.

He only looked at it.

He asked himself silently, without witness and without expectation of an immediate answer, what all of this was for. Not who commanded, not who obeyed, but the meaning of everything he had lived through.

He found no answer.

And for the first time, he did not force himself to stop searching.

In the distance, the adhan came again. Not closer than before. Not clearer. But now Alaric did not hear it only as sound. He heard it as a marker, a sign that another system existed beyond the one he knew. A system with rules, obedience, and discipline too, but somehow it did not feel the same.

He did not know the difference. He only knew the comparison now lived inside his mind.

And comparison was the beginning of change. Alaric remained a Crusader that night. He still wore armor. Still obeyed orders. Still stood in line. But something inside him was no longer entirely in the same place.

And he knew, with an unpleasant certainty, that the shift would not stop here.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***