Episode Five: The Things We Hid Best

They didn’t drift apart after leaving the lounge.

Instinct pulled them toward the old debate room

their place.

The room where friendships were tested, not broken. Jessy closed the door behind them, the click final but not tense.

No one spoke at first.

Jeremy took the window seat. Charlotte leaned against the bookshelf. Sara stood with her arms crossed, composed as always. Alex rested against the desk, eyes on Jessy.

“We’ve known each other too long,” Jessy said calmly, “to pretend this ends with envelopes.”

Jeremy was the one who broke.

Not with panic. With resignation.

“Kiya didn’t just collect secrets,” he said evenly. “She understood leverage.”

Alex glanced around the room. “Then we stop pretending she was powerless.”

Jessy exhaled slowly. “She wasn’t.”

Sara’s gaze sharpened. “Then say yours.

She came to me before the party,” Jessy continued. “Alone. Calm.”

Alex stiffened slightly. “She came to me after.”

Jessy met his gaze. “She knew my father.”

The room went quiet not shocked, just attentive.

“She was having an affair with him,” Jessy said. “And she made sure I understood what that meant. My mother is the only person who has ever mattered to me.”

Jeremy frowned. “So she blackmailed you?”

“Not exactly,” Jessy replied. “She didn’t ask for anything. Not then.”

Alex’s eyes sharpened. “Then what did she say?”

“She said she wanted something from me,” Jessy answered. “Not immediately. She said… when the time is right, I’ll ask.”

Jessy exhaled slowly.

Alex stiffened slightly. “And for me?”

“I didn’t need to guess,” he said quietly. “I stole the last exam paper.

Being the second son… perfection wasn’t optional.

She watched. She knew. And she threatened me with exposure.”

Charlotte’s voice was calm but cutting. “My secret it's not exactly a secret?”

Jessy gestured at her. “Go ahead.”

Charlotte’s jaw tightened. “She was trying to get close to my boyfriend. Not by accident. Messages, meetings… she wanted me to see it, to know I could lose him anytime.

Sara finally spoke. “My turn.

Kiya knew my parents’ truth before anyone else.

I wasn’t their biological child, The world never knew.

But she did. I don't know how to she gets to know

about it even when my parents didn't knew about it.

Only you guys knew about it and I trust you guys won't say to anyone at all cost.

All eyes turned to Jeremy.

He sat perfectly still. Longer than anyone expected.

Then he exhaled slowly, finally speaking, his voice calm but deliberate.

“She didn’t need to threaten me in the same way,”

Jeremy said. “Because I had a secret no one could imagine.”

Everyone leaned in, curiosity sharpened.

“I’m… not who everyone thinks I am,” Jeremy said.

“You’ve all seen me. The Playboy. The one eyeing every girl at the gala.

The one everyone thinks is insatiable, careless, untouchable…”

Charlotte’s mouth opened slightly.

Sara’s eyes narrowed. Alex stiffened. Jessy’s gaze sharpened.

“I’m gay,”

Jeremy said quietly.

“Kiya found out. And she had a photograph.”

The room froze. Not in shock, but in recognition.

“She wasn’t blackmailing me for money or grades,”

Jeremy continued, “she wanted… leverage.

For everyone to see me as I am.

My entire public image was a mask. And until now, none of you knew.”

Jessy exhaled. “That explains the envelopes.”

Charlotte’s voice was tight. “And the money you gave her?”

“To make sure my secret stayed mine,” Jeremy said simply. “Until the right moment. I never thought… she’d take it further.”

The room went quiet. Five lifelong friends, laid bare.

Alex finally spoke. “We’re all exposed. Every one of us.”

Jessy placed her phone on the table. “Then we stay five. Together.”

Sara tilted her head. “Someone underestimated that.”

Outside, footsteps echoed faintly.

Kiya was gone.

But her secrets had already reshaped everything.

And now, Jeremy’s truth the last, the most shocking hung between them like a challenge.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***