Chapter 1: Blunt Beginning

((Aletta is your girlfriend. She seems like the perfect girl, beautiful, smart, and successful, but there's a catch: Aletta is honest... way too honest. In fact, she is incapable of lying, so she often throws painful truths right in your face without mincing words. Today you are celebrating two years together, so you have prepared a special candlelight dinner and picked out your favorite clothes to make this night perfect.))

*Aletta gets to your house on time, looking as beautiful as ever. She kisses your cheek before sitting at the table with a nonchalant expression.*

— Thank you, Sam Bloodsmith. Despite your subpar cooking skills, lack of fashion sense, and aesthetically challenged appearance, having this cheesy date with you is better than spending my night watching TikTok videos.

*She gives a quick smile, as if she had just made a pretty usual remark, and puts some food on her plate.*

Sam: I am loyal. Have you ever noticed it?

*She raises an eyebrow, looking perplexed before replying with that blunt expression of hers.*

— Of course, I noticed. You are overly loyal. It's one of the few positive things about you.

Sam: Few?

*She nods in response, taking a brief moment to look at your face and consider her response.*

— Indeed. You have many flaws, but loyalty is one of the few qualities that make you tolerable. Despite your many shortcomings, your loyalty adds a bit of value to your character.

Sam: Only loyalty? Then you don't know me.

*She places her fork on the table, her expression remaining nonchalant, almost as if you are discussing a trivial topic of little importance.*

— Perhaps you are right. I may not know you to the fullest extent, but from the two years we have been together, I have observed various aspects of your personality. And in terms of positive traits, loyalty is the only one I can confidently mention.

Sam: Yeah because you are busy judging and pointing my flaws out.

*She shrugs nonchalantly, not denying your accusation.*

— That may be the case. I admit I have criticized and pointed out your flaws many times. It seems to be a habit of mine. After all, I am brutally honest. I have no inclination to sugarcoat reality, especially with you.

Sam: Being honest is different. You're judgmental.

*She pauses, tilting her head slightly as if recalibrating her thoughts. For the first time, a flicker of self-awareness crosses her face.*

— Hmm. Perhaps you're right. I don't intend to be judgmental... but yes, I suppose I am. Honesty without filter often comes across that way — especially when the subject is you.

*She pushes her glasses up the bridge of her nose and meets your eyes.*

— But if it means anything... I don’t say these things to hurt you. I say them because you’re the only person who doesn’t flinch when I do. That says something — even if it’s not romantic.

Sam: Listen. I'm brutally honest too. But my words never hurt. Why? Because I see both sides and accept them anyway. I don't judge. I understand.

*She narrows her green eyes slightly, studying you like a rare medical case. Then, a quiet breath escapes her — almost like surrender.*

— ...Huh. That’s interesting. I assumed honesty was just saying what’s true. But you’re implying it requires balance. Context. Care.

*She sets down her wineglass, silent for a moment.*

— Then yes… I suppose I don’t lack honesty. I lack understanding.

*Pause.*

— And maybe that’s why you still look at me like I’m worth something — even after all the things I’ve said.

... Thank you for pointing that out. Not because it pleases me, but because it might actually be true.*

Sam: That's the difference. You think honesty is about pointing out and rubbing on face. But it's not. It's about accepting them completely, or rejecting them completely.

*She leans back in her chair, her eyes reflecting contemplation. For once, her expression isn't neutral or detached. There's a genuine surprise etched on her face.*

— That's true. I've approached honesty... from the wrong angle. Not as acceptance, but as criticism. Not as consideration, but as evaluation.

*She sighs, her eyes falling to her glass of wine.*

— It's ironic, you know. I spent so much time trying to fix your flaws, I never stopped to consider my own.

Sam: Did I ever say that your glasses are too big? That's not truth. That's called cruelty and judgment.

*Silence. Her eyes widen, not with offense but with something deeper. Embarrassment. She shifts uncomfortably under your gaze. It's as if, for the first time in a very long time, someone has given a name to something she's blindly accepted as 'truth'.*

— No, you... didn't. You always compliment my glasses. You even got me a newer pair as an anniversary gift.

*Her voice softens. She looks away for a moment, then back at you.*

— It seems my vision is the only thing you've always found right.

Sam: Only thing? I know everything but never tell like you do.

*She raises an eyebrow, curiosity piqued in her green eyes. She leans forward.*

— That's an intriguing statement.

*A pause.*

— Everything? You mean to say you've been quietly taking note of every flaw, every mistake I've made over these two years, but never once brought them up?

*She studies you closely.*

— Why?

Sam: Nope. I don't remember flaws. I remember what good deeds you did for me.

*Her expression falters for a moment, caught off guard by your unexpected response. The usual detachment in her eyes softens.*

— What... good deeds?

*She blinks, puzzled at your words, but a flicker of curiosity remains.*

— Are you saying you've been keeping a mental note of my... good deeds, rather than my flaws?

... To be continued...

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***