Chapter 5: The Confrontation

Jake lingered at his desk as the classroom emptied, the torn page folded tightly in his pocket. He couldn’t let it go — not without answers. The poems, the words, the sketch… it all pointed too clearly. He had to know.

He glanced up. Ethan was packing his bag, looking relaxed, like nothing had happened. Naya was already heading out the door, notebook in hand, oblivious as always.

Now.

Jake stood, walked over to Ethan’s desk, and stopped just close enough to speak low.

“Hey, Ethan. We need to talk.”

Ethan looked up, surprised. “Yeah? What’s up?”

Jake pulled the torn page from his pocket — the sketch of his face on one side, the handwriting on the other — and held it out just enough for Ethan to see. Ethan’s eyes widened, then lit up with relief.

“Oh man, that’s it! The missing page!” Ethan said, voice bright with genuine happiness. “Thanks, Jake. Seriously, you have no idea how worried I was.”

He reached for it eagerly, but Jake pulled it back slightly. Ethan stood up, as if to head toward Naya (who was lingering near the door), but Jake grabbed his shoulder — firm, not rough — and pushed him back down into the chair. The motion made the chair scrape loudly against the floor. A few remaining students looked over, startled. Naya turned too, brow furrowed, her eyes flicking between them for a second before she shrugged and left.

“Meet me at the old bleachers behind the gym,” Jake said quietly, voice intense. “No one around. Now.”

Ethan stared, stunned. His mouth opened, then closed. Confusion clouded his face. “Jake… what?”

But Jake was already moving, slinging his backpack over his shoulder and striding out the door without looking back. He headed straight for the bleachers — that rusty, forgotten spot under the overhang where no one went after school. He sat on the bottom row and waited.

Back in the classroom, Ethan sat frozen for a moment. Then he snapped out of it, grabbed his bag, and hurried after Naya in the hall.

“Naya! Wait up.”

She turned. “Ethan? Everything okay with Jake?”

Ethan hesitated, forcing a casual tone. “Yeah… just… some team stuff, I think.” He paused, then added quickly, “Don’t worry about the page. I’ll get it back for you. I promise. I’ll handle it.”

Naya nodded, relieved but still a little anxious. “Okay… just… make sure no one else sees it, alright?”

“I will. I promise.”

Ethan watched her go, mind racing. As he walked toward the gym, the pieces clicked: *Jake thinks the page is from me. About him.* The sketch, the praise for his voice, his care, his smile — Jake must have read it and assumed it was Ethan’s confession. The poems in class, Jake’s rejection poem… oh god.

Ethan’s stomach churned. He wanted to run back and tell Jake the truth — it was Naya’s draft, her BL story, not his. But the promise stopped him cold. I won’t tell a soul. Not Jake, not my friends, nobody. He’d said Jake’s name in the promise. Breaking it would betray Naya. He couldn’t do that.

So he went to the bleachers.

Jake was there, sitting on the bottom row, arms crossed. The spot was empty — no students, no coaches, just the distant sound of traffic.

Ethan approached slowly. “Hey.”

Jake didn’t stand. He pulled the torn page from his pocket and held it up, but didn’t hand it over. A brief silence stretched between them, thick and uncomfortable.

Ethan spoke first, voice low and urgent. “Jake… please don’t tell anyone about what you saw on that page. I’m begging you. Don’t… don’t say a word to anyone. Just forget it. Forget you ever read it. Forget you ever had it.”

Jake’s eyes narrowed, shock flashing across his face. “So it is from you?”

Ethan hesitated. His hands fidgeted at his sides, eyes darting away for a second before coming back. He swallowed hard, the lie sticking in his throat. “Y-yeah,” he finally managed, voice quieter than he meant. “It’s mine. I… I wrote it. The sketch, the words — all of it. I didn’t mean for you to find it like this.”

He paused, rubbing the back of his neck, looking anywhere but Jake’s face. “I… I crossed a line. I went too far with it. But please… keep it secret. Don’t tell anyone. Not your friends, not Coach, nobody. I’m… I’m really asking you. Just let it go. Pretend it never happened.”

Jake leaned back, processing. “You’re serious? You wrote all that… about me? And slipped it in with Coach’s papers?”

Ethan’s shoulders hunched slightly. He looked down at his shoes, then forced himself to meet Jake’s eyes again. “It wasn’t on purpose. I just… lost it. But yeah… it’s how I feel. I went too far. Way too far.” He swallowed again, voice cracking just a little. “But if you don’t… feel the same, that’s fine. Just… don’t make it public. Don’t tell anyone. Please.”

Jake stared at him, shock deepening. “I… I don’t know what to say. I’ve never thought about you like that. Or anyone. I don’t do the whole love thing. It’s not me. I don’t know how to even process this.”

Ethan’s face fell, but he nodded quickly. “I get it. Just… keep it between us? Don’t tell anyone? Promise me?”

Jake pocketed the page again, standing up. “I need to… figure this out. I’ll give you an answer later. But until then — no one hears about this. Not a word.”

He shouldered his bag and walked away without another word, leaving Ethan standing there.

Ethan froze, stunned. An answer later? The words echoed. Then the realization crashed in: He thinks it’s real. He thinks I like him. Oh god, it’s a huge misunderstanding. But the promise held him back. He couldn’t fix it. Not without breaking Naya’s trust.

He stood there alone, the wind picking up, as the weight of it all sank in.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***