CHAPTER 4 "What The Eyes Remember"

Sophia didn't move.

She stood in the doorway of the small reading room, letter box pressed against her chest, watching the old man's eyes fill with something that looked like a lifetime of waiting finally reaching its shore.

Edward Cross didn't look away from her face.

His pale blue eyes moved slowly — from her eyes, to her nose, to the way she stood. Like he was reading a book he had memorized long ago but hadn't opened in decades.

"You look like her," he said finally. His voice was barely above a whisper. "Around the eyes. Margaret always had eyes that looked like they were keeping a secret."

Sophia felt something tighten in her throat.

She stepped inside carefully and closed the door behind her. The reading room was small and warm. Bookshelves lined every wall from floor to ceiling. The classical music was coming from a small radio on the windowsill. Outside the window, snow was falling steadily now over the dark Boston streets.

She pulled a chair close and sat down across from him.

For a moment neither of them spoke.

Then Sophia set the letter box on the small table between them.

Edward Cross looked at it for a long time. His weathered hands gripped the arms of his chair. His jaw tightened slightly. Like a man trying very hard to hold himself together.

"Where did you find it?" he asked.

"Behind the wardrobe," Sophia said softly. "Under a loose floorboard. I was clearing out her house today."

He nodded slowly.

"I gave it to her," he said. "The box. Not the letter. I never gave her the letter." He paused. "I made the box myself. I was never a talented man with wood but I wanted to make her something with my own hands. I gave it to her one Christmas and told her to keep things in it. Small things. Things that mattered."

"She did," Sophia said. "She kept your letter in it."

Edward closed his eyes briefly.

"She never told me she found it," he said. "I hid it in that box one afternoon when she wasn't home. I thought — if she finds it, perhaps that means something. Perhaps the universe will decide for me what I was too afraid to decide for myself." He opened his eyes again. "But she never said a word. And I was too frightened to ask."

Sophia looked at the old man sitting before her — ninety one years old, sharp minded, quietly heartbroken — and felt the full weight of what fear could cost a person settle over her like cold water.

"Did you love her for a long time?" she asked.

Edward smiled. It was a small smile. Tired and tender at the same time.

"From the very first autumn," he said. "We met at the university. September, 1955. She was studying literature. I was a young lecturer who thought he knew everything about words." He let out a soft breath of something that might have been a laugh. "Margaret taught me that knowing words and knowing how to use them are two entirely different things."

"What was she like?" Sophia asked. "When she was young?"

Edward was quiet for a moment. His pale eyes moved to the falling snow outside the window.

"Extraordinary," he said simply. "She walked into a room and every conversation immediately became more interesting. She argued about literature like it was oxygen. She laughed easily but cried at things most people didn't even notice — a bird with an injured wing, a child crying in a market, an old man eating lunch alone."

Sophia felt tears prick behind her eyes.

That was her grandmother. Exactly her grandmother.

"She sounds wonderful," she managed.

"She was the finest person I ever knew," Edward said quietly. "And I wasted forty years standing close enough to touch her and never once reaching out."

The words landed in the small warm room like stones dropped in still water.

Sophia looked down at the letter box.

"Mr. Cross," she said carefully. "Can I ask — did she ever give you any sign? Any indication at all that she might have felt the same?"

Edward was silent for so long that Sophia thought he hadn't heard her.

Then he reached into the pocket of his navy cardigan.

And pulled out a small folded piece of paper.

Old paper. Cream colored. Slightly yellowed at the edges.

He held it out to Sophia with a trembling hand.

"She slipped this under my office door," he said. "February 14th, 1962. I found it that evening. I have carried it every day since."

Sophia took it gently.

She unfolded it.

Inside, in her grandmother's handwriting — elegant, slightly hurried — were four words.

Just four words.

"I know, Edward. Me too."

Sophia pressed her hand over her mouth.

The snow fell outside. The classical music played softly. And Edward Cross sat in his armchair with sixty years of silence finally breaking open in his pale blue eyes.

"She knew," Sophia whispered.

"She knew," he confirmed. His voice cracked for the first time. "And we still said nothing. We were both so afraid of losing the friendship that we lost everything else instead."

He looked at Sophia directly then. Completely. Like a man passing something precious into younger hands.

"Don't do that," he said quietly. "Whatever it is in your life that you are afraid to say — don't do what we did. Don't let fear write your story."

Sophia couldn't speak.

She just sat there holding her grandmother's four words in her hands while the snow covered Boston in white silence outside.

And somewhere in the back of her mind, a face appeared that she had been trying very hard not to think about for the past six months.

A face she had walked away from without explanation.

A face she had been too afraid to turn back to.

To be continued...

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***