I loved you first

The city was quiet at 2 a.m.

Chole couldn’t sleep.

Not because she was anxious.

But because she felt safe.

And safety was unfamiliar.

She stepped quietly out of the guest room in Gavin’s penthouse, barefoot against the cool marble floor. The lights in the living room were dim.

Gavin was awake.

Of course he was.

He sat on the couch, sleeves rolled up, reading something on his tablet. He looked up immediately when he sensed her presence.

“You can’t sleep,” he said.

It wasn’t a question.

She shook her head slightly. “Too much in my mind.”

He set the tablet aside.

“Come here.”

Not commanding.

Inviting.

She walked over and sat beside him, closer this time. Not accidental. Not hesitant.

Intentional.

For a few moments, neither of them spoke.

Then she asked quietly—

“When did you start loving me?”

Gavin didn’t answer immediately.

He leaned back, eyes lifting toward the ceiling as if replaying something old.

“Second year of university,” he said finally.

Her brows furrowed. “That early?”

He nodded slightly.

“You were arguing with a professor.”

She blinked. “What?”

“You were furious because he dismissed your proposal in front of the class. Everyone else stayed quiet.”

A faint memory surfaced.

“I told him he was wrong,” she murmured.

“You told him he lacked vision,” Gavin corrected calmly.

She almost smiled.

“I thought you were reckless,” he continued. “Prideful. Too bold.”

“And yet?”

“And yet,” his voice softened, “you stayed back after class and apologized. Not because you were wrong. But because you thought you embarrassed him.”

Her breath caught.

She barely remembered that.

“I realized something that day,” Gavin said quietly. “You fight hard. But you care harder.”

The room felt smaller.

Warmer.

“I started watching you after that,” he admitted.

“Watching me?” she teased faintly.

“Observing,” he corrected smoothly.

She rolled her eyes slightly.

But her chest felt tight.

“I knew you’d become powerful,” he continued. “But I was afraid of something.”

“What?”

“That someone would mistake your strength for ambition.”

Her throat tightened.

Logan did.

“I didn’t confess immediately,” Gavin said. “You were chasing big things. I didn’t want to be something that slowed you down.”

She looked at him carefully.

“You were never something that slowed me down.”

“I know that now,” he said softly.

Silence stretched.

Then he added—

“I loved you before you became successful. Before you built anything. Before anyone else noticed you.”

Her eyes burned again.

“And when I confessed…” he continued slowly, “I already knew you would say no.”

She stared at him.

“You knew?”

“Yes.”

“Then why say it?”

He looked at her fully.

“Because loving you silently was heavier than losing you honestly.”

The words hit her like a wave.

In her past life, she thought his confession was sudden.

Impulsive.

But he had loved her for years.

Quietly.

Steadily.

Without demanding attention.

“I was cruel,” she whispered.

“You were young.”

“I hurt you.”

“You chose what you thought was right.”

“And you left.”

His jaw tightened slightly.

“I stayed until I couldn’t.”

The weight of that sentence pressed against her chest.

She remembered his eyes the day she rejected him.

Not angry.

Just… empty.

“After you chose Logan,” Gavin continued, voice lower now, “I promised myself something.”

Her heart pounded.

“What?”

“That if you ever came back to me… I would never let you walk away again.”

The air shifted.

Not possessive.

Protective.

She studied him carefully.

“And if I hadn’t come back?”

He didn’t hesitate.

“I would’ve loved you anyway.”

The simplicity of it shattered her.

No drama.

No bitterness.

Just truth.

She leaned forward slightly.

“There’s something I need to tell you,” she whispered.

His expression sharpened.

“What?”

She almost told him.

About the rooftop. About dying. About watching him poison himself.

But she stopped.

Not yet.

Instead she said—

“In this life… I won’t choose wrong.”

His gaze softened in a way that was almost dangerous.

“Then don’t.”

He reached up slowly.

Not to pull her in.

Not to rush.

He simply brushed a strand of hair behind her ear.

The gesture was gentle.

Reverent.

“Chole,” he said quietly, “I don’t need you to fight for me.”

Her breath trembled.

“I just need you to stay.”

That broke her more than any grand declaration.

Because Logan wanted control.

Gavin wanted presence.

She closed the distance between them.

Rested her forehead lightly against his.

“I’m staying,” she whispered.

And for the first time since returning—

She meant it without fear.

Gavin’s hand slid carefully to her waist.

Not demanding.

Not claiming.

Just holding.

Like something precious.

Something once lost.

Something never to be lost again.

And in that quiet room—

Before revenge. Before exposure. Before the storm—

They chose each other.

Softly.

Completely.

Across the city—

Logan stared at a security photo on his phone.

Chole.

Entering Gavin Turner’s building the previous night.

His jaw tightened.

So that’s where you’ve been.

His fingers tapped slowly against the desk.

He wasn’t panicking.

He was calculating.

“If she wants to play,” he muttered quietly, “then let’s raise the stakes.”

And somewhere behind him—

Lisa watched his expression change.

And realized—

Chole wasn’t the only one hiding something.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***