What Breaks In Silence

The basement was quieter than it had ever been, not because nothing had happened, but because too much had.

Lavy sat where she always did, her back against the cold stone wall, chains resting loosely around her wrists. The torchlight flickered faintly, shadows stretching and shrinking across the walls like restless ghosts, but for once, she didn’t comment on it. She didn’t speak at all.

The images wouldn’t leave.

They replayed without mercy, sharp and unrelenting. The kneeling figures. The stillness before each strike. The sound, dull, final, impossible to ignore. She could still see the way one of them had shifted slightly, as if trying to say something before it was too late. She could still feel the moment her own breath had caught, the way her body had reacted before her mind could catch up.

“They came for you.”

Grace’s voice echoed in her memory, calm and certain.

Lavy shut her eyes tightly, but it didn’t help.

It made it worse because now she didn’t just see it, she felt it. The weight of it pressing into her chest, tightening with every breath. Her fingers curled slightly against the chains, the cold metal grounding her just enough to remind her she was still here.

Still alive.

“They didn’t deserve that,” she whispered into the silence, though no one was there to hear it.

Her voice didn’t sound like her own. It was quieter, unsteady.

The kind of voice she never allowed herself to have.

Her head dropped slightly, resting against her knees as she pulled them closer, something she hadn’t done since the first night she was brought here. The posture felt unfamiliar now, too exposed, too honest but she didn’t correct it.

Because there was no one here to see or so she thought.

A tear slipped before she could stop it. Then another.

She didn’t make a sound at first, as if silence alone could contain everything building inside her. But the more she tried to hold it back, the harder it became. Her breathing grew uneven, her shoulders tightening as the memories refused to loosen their grip.

“I didn’t even know them,” she murmured, her voice breaking slightly. “And they still...”

She stopped because finishing that sentence would make it real.

Would make it heavier.

Would make it harder to carry.

Her hand moved instinctively to her face, wiping quickly at the tears as if she could erase them before they existed, but more followed anyway, quiet and stubborn.

Lavy laughed softly under her breath.

A broken sound.

“This is pathetic,” she whispered but she didn’t stop, not this time.

Above, the palace slept but not everyone.

Grace stood by the window in her chamber, her gaze fixed somewhere beyond the kingdom, though she wasn’t really seeing anything at all. The night was still, the kind of stillness that usually brought clarity.

Tonight, it didn’t.

Her thoughts returned again and again to the same moment.

The way Lavy had looked, not defiant, not mocking, just still and that unsettled her more than anything else.

Grace exhaled slowly, her fingers curling slightly against the edge of the window.

“...necessary,” she repeated under her breath but the word didn’t land the same way it used to because this time she remembered the silence that followed.

Morning came slowly.

Not in light, but in sound.

The distant movement of the palace waking, footsteps returning, voices low and controlled.

The basement door opened as it always did but something had changed. Lavy didn’t look up immediately.

She had already wiped away any trace of the night before, her posture returned to its usual controlled stillness, her expression composed. Only the faint redness in her eyes betrayed anything but even that was subtle, easy to miss.

Grace stepped inside alone, as always.

Her gaze moved to Lavy immediately and stopped, just for a second because she noticed, of course she did.

“You didn’t sleep,”Grace said.

It wasn’t a question.

Lavy let out a quiet breath, her tone returning to something familiar.“I tried. Your hospitality makes it difficult.”

Grace didn’t respond right away. Instead, she placed the tray down, food, water, the same as the past few days but she didn’t leave.

“...you’re quieter,” she said.

Lavy tilted her head slightly.“Am I?”

“Yes.”

“That sounds disappointing.”

“It is.”

A pause. Something unspoken passed between them.

Lavy reached for the water first this time, her movements slower than usual but controlled. She didn’t look at Grace while she drank.

“...they came because of me,”she said finally.

Grace didn’t deny it.

“Yes.”

Lavy nodded faintly, as if confirming something to herself.“Then I watched them die because of me.”

Silence but then,

“They chose that risk,”Grace replied.

Lavy let out a small breath, not quite a laugh.“That doesn’t make it easier.”

“No,”Grace said.

And that was it, no justification, no argument, just the truth.

For a moment, neither of them spoke. Then Lavy glanced up, her expression steadier now, though something deeper had shifted beneath it.

“You’re still going to do it again, aren’t you?”she asked.

Grace met her gaze.

“If they come again, yes.”

Lavy held that gaze for a long second. Then nodded.

“....I figured.”

The silence that followed wasn’t sharp this time. It was heavier, more aware and somewhere beneath the surface, something had changed in both of them.

Not enough to be named, not enough to be stopped but enough to matter

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***