Stars Aligned But Not For Us

The first time our paths crossed was inside a Mobile Legends lobby—completely random, just two players matched by the game’s system, nothing more. Back then, I had no idea this stranger would become the person who fit every single piece of my soul, and also the one who would make my heart ache the most.

We started playing together almost every day after that. We’d queue up at the same hours, stay online until late, and slowly, we started talking beyond the game. That was when I noticed the first strange, wonderful coincidence: we were both Mythic 8. Not just the same rank—exactly the same number of points. It felt like fate itself had deliberately paired us, like we were on the exact same level in every way.

Then came more similarities, one after another, like little gifts the universe kept handing me. We were both HUMSS students, studying the same things, talking about the same lessons, understanding each other’s school struggles without even explaining much. We were both born in February—me on the 15th, him on the 21st, only six days apart. We even shared the exact same life story when it came to our dreams: both of us once wanted to be flight attendants, daydreaming about flying and seeing the world, until one day we both changed our minds, deciding instead we wanted to join the police force. Even the smallest, silliest things lined up—there were days we’d message each other at the same time, saying we were eating the exact same meal, at the exact same hour, with no plan or mention of it beforehand.

It wasn’t just shared interests or matching facts, either. It felt like looking into a mirror. We were both quiet, reserved, the type of people who didn’t open up to just anyone—introverts who preferred listening over talking, who kept our worlds small and safe. He was literally the boy version of me. I understood his silences, his moods, his way of thinking, his little quirks and attitude, because I was exactly the same. My parents were Pisces and Aquarius, and they were the most perfect couple I’d ever known; when I realized he was Pisces and I was Aquarius too, it felt like proof—like this connection wasn’t just chance, it was written somewhere long before we ever met.

I started falling slowly, softly, and completely. Every match, every chat, every quiet moment we shared made me surer: this was it. This was the person I’d been waiting for.

I tested it once, on the last day of December. It was a silly prank, really—I typed out that I liked him, my heart beating fast while I waited for his reply. When it came, it made my breath catch: “Why don’t we try?”

I re-read that line a hundred times, kept it saved in my messages. It wasn’t a rejection. It was an invitation. I told myself he felt it too, that he just needed a little push. I got another chance on April 1st—April Fool’s Day, the perfect day to say things you really mean, hidden behind a joke. I teased him again, saying I liked him. His reply came quickly, and it made my chest feel tight, equal parts hope and longing: “It seems true, don’t play other people’s feelings.”

I thought those words meant everything. I thought he was telling me he wanted it to be real too. I thought I was right there, right on the edge of having everything I ever wanted.

Then he told me about her.

Her name never left my mind after that. She was a Taurus girl, and everyone always said Taurus and Pisces were a perfect match—written in the stars, high compatibility, meant to be. People also said Aquarius and Pisces were opposite, clashing, never meant to work. I heard him say it himself, so many times: “She had everything I wanted.”

He told me she fell first, but he fell harder. He told me how much he liked her, how he thought she was perfect, how she was everything he’d ever looked for. But then came the part that broke him, and broke me too, just listening: she left him. She couldn’t handle his attitude—his quietness, his moods, the parts of him that were just him. She got tired of it, gave up, and walked away without looking back.

And after she was gone, he looked so empty, so hurt, and he swore it to his life—like it was the most serious vow he’d ever make—that he would never, ever fall in love again. He said no one would ever compare to her, no one would ever be enough, that his heart was already hers and it would stay that way forever. He said love only ends in pain, that no one would ever stay, so he’d rather close his heart completely than go through that hurt again.

I listened to every word, smiling and comforting him while my own heart broke into pieces right there inside my chest.

He didn’t see me. He didn’t see that while she was perfect on paper, I was perfect for him. She liked the idea of him, but couldn’t handle his reality. I loved his reality. I loved his attitude, his silences, his quiet heart, every single part of him that she’d found too hard to keep. She was the match the stars said was good, but I was the match that actually fit. We were two halves of the same soul, born into different bodies, different lives, but made to understand each other without even speaking.

He didn’t notice that even when he thought she was everything, even when he was already hurting over her, when I told him I liked him, he asked to try. He didn’t notice that he told me not to play with his feelings, because my feelings were the only ones that mattered to him, even when he didn’t know it himself. He didn’t notice that all the little coincidences, all the shared dreams, all the things that made us the same—they weren’t random. They were the universe screaming that I was the one meant for him.

Now, I’m still here. I still play with him, still talk to him, still laugh at his jokes, still comfort him when he’s sad. I’m still the one who understands him best, the one who never gets tired of him, the one who would never ever leave him because of who he is.

I look at him sometimes, when we’re in the middle of a match, or just chatting late at night, and I think about how everything aligned so perfectly for us—except our hearts. The stars brought us together, gave us every reason to be each other’s, gave us every similarity that could exist… but they aligned him to love someone else, and left him so broken he swore he’d never love again.

He fell for her, and he thinks she was his everything. He thinks no one can ever be worth loving again. But I know the truth: I’m the one who matches him. I’m the one who stays. I’m the one who loves every part of him, even the parts he thinks no one will ever want.

And even if he never sees it, even if he keeps his promise to never fall in love again, even if I only ever get to be his best friend, his favorite teammate, the one who listens—even if I never get to be the one he loves back… I’m still glad. I’m glad I met him. I’m glad I got to know him. I’m glad I got to love him, quietly and truly, even if the stars aligned everything else right, but not our ending.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***