Chapter 5: The Hollow Space Beside Me

The engine of the SUV didn't just stop; it died with a pathetic, wheezing rattle that seemed to mock the silence of the morning. For a long, agonizing minute, nobody moved. The air inside the car was thick, smelling of old leather and the lingering scent of Asher’s expensive cologne—sandalwood and vanilla—which now felt like a punch to the gut.

Daniel sat frozen, his hand still shaped as if it were holding Asher’s. He stared at the empty seat, at the lone Italian loafer that looked so small and abandoned on the upholstery.

"Asher?" Daniel’s voice was a ragged whisper. He turned his head slowly, his eyes wide and glazed. "Ethan? Where did he go? He was right here. I was holding his hand. I was holding it."

Ethan didn't answer. He was slumped over the steering wheel, his forehead resting against the leather, his chest heaving. Beside him, Lucian was shaking, his hands gripped so tightly around the cast-iron skillet that his fingers were turning white.

"The figures," Ed stammered from the back, his voice sounding thin and brittle like dry parchment. "There were four of them. Not five. Daniel, there were only four of us standing in the road."

Daniel didn't listen. He lunged into the backseat, grabbing the empty air where Asher should have been. "Asher! This isn't funny! Ash!" He threw open the car door and stumbled out into the gravel. The morning sun was bright now, but it offered no warmth. The house loomed over them, its windows shimmering like oily eyes.

"He’s in the house," Daniel gasped, spinning around to look at the towering Victorian. "He didn't make it out. The loop... it took him back before we even hit the gate."

"Daniel, wait!" Ethan shouted, finally finding his voice and scrambling out of the car. He caught Daniel by the shoulders just as the larger man started to bolt toward the porch. "Look at the door, Dan! Look at the house!"

The front door of Blackwood Manor was wide open. But it wasn't the dark, empty foyer they had fled minutes ago. The interior was glowing with a soft, warm, amber light. From inside, they could hear the faint, muffled sound of music—the upbeat pop playlist they had been playing on their first day.

And then, they heard the laughter.

It was Asher’s laugh. Clear, bright, and full of the bubbly energy he always had when he was teasing Daniel.

"You hear that?" Daniel cried, wrenching himself free from Ethan’s grip. "He’s in there! He’s okay!"

"Dan, stop! It’s a trap! It has to be!" Lucian yelled, stepping out of the car and brandishing the skillet like a shield. "We just saw ourselves dead in the road! This house is playing with us!"

But Daniel was already halfway up the porch steps. His heart was a frantic, screaming thing in his chest. Logic had been burned away by pure, desperate instinct. He didn't care about the loop. He didn't care about the creature with the slit for a mouth. He just wanted the man who made him feel like he belonged in the world.

"Asher!" Daniel roared, bursting through the front door.

He skidded to a halt in the foyer. The house looked perfect. The dust motes were gone. The shattered glass from the chandelier was missing—the crystals hung intact, sparkling in the sunlight. The scent of lavender and old books was back, sweet and inviting.

"In the kitchen, big guy!" Asher’s voice called out, sounding muffled by the walls. "I’m making the coffee! You’re late!"

Daniel ran toward the kitchen, his heavy boots thudding against the pristine wood. Ethan, Lucian, and Ed followed close behind, their faces a mix of terror and a flickering, dangerous hope.

Daniel burst through the swinging doors and stopped dead.

Asher was there. He was standing by the stove, wearing his favorite oversized silk robe, humming to himself as he poured water into the French press. The sunlight was hitting his blonde hair, making him look like something out of a dream. He looked up and beamed, his eyes crinkling at the corners.

"There you are," Asher said, his voice warm and melodic. "I thought you’d sleep through the whole morning. Want some toast? Ed actually found the toaster in the basement."

Daniel stood frozen, his breath coming in jagged hitches. He took a step forward, his hand reaching out. "Ash? Is it... is it really you?"

Asher tilted his head, a playful, confused look on his face. "Of course it’s me, silly. Who else would it be? Did you have a nightmare or something? You look like you’ve seen a ghost."

Daniel didn't wait. He crossed the kitchen in two strides and hauled Asher into his arms, crushing him against his chest. He buried his face in the crook of Asher’s neck, sobbing openly now. Asher felt warm. He felt solid. He smelled like that sandalwood cologne.

"I thought I lost you," Daniel choked out. "I thought the loop took you. We were in the car, and then you were gone..."

Asher laughed softly, his hands coming up to rub Daniel’s back. "The car? Dan, we haven't even finished unpacking the SUV. We just got here yesterday. You’re definitely stressed from the move."

Behind them, Ethan, Lucian, and Ed stood in the doorway, staring at the scene with wide, hollow eyes.

"Asher," Ethan said, his voice trembling. "What day is it?"

Asher looked over Daniel’s shoulder, smiling at Ethan. "It’s Saturday, Ethan. The first official day of our empire. Why are you all wearing those dirty clothes? And Lucian... why are you holding a frying pan like a weapon?"

Lucian looked down at the skillet, then back at Asher. "We... we were trying to leave. The gates were locked. The salt turned black."

Asher’s smile didn't fade, but it didn't reach his eyes. "Locked? The gates are wide open. I saw the mailman drive by ten minutes ago. You guys are acting so weird."

Ed stepped forward, his medical brain struggling to process the reality in front of him. He looked at the floor—no black liquid. He looked at the window—the salt line was gone, but the wood wasn't charred. "Asher, look at my hand."

Ed held up his hand. It was covered in small cuts from the shattered chandelier glass.

Asher looked at the hand, and for a split second, his expression shifted. The warmth drained from his face, leaving it blank and grey. His eyes seemed to flicker, the blue iris momentarily replaced by a dull, flat charcoal.

"There’s nothing there, Ed," Asher said. His voice had dropped an octave, losing its melodic quality. "Your hand is perfectly fine."

Daniel pulled back, looking down at Ed’s hand. To Daniel’s eyes, the cuts were deep and bleeding. But as he looked back at Asher, he saw his boyfriend’s smile return, brighter and more perfect than before.

"See?" Asher chirped. "Perfectly fine. Now, sit down. I made pancakes."

Asher turned back to the stove, but as he moved, the silk of his robe shifted. Daniel’s heart stopped.

On the back of Asher’s neck, just below the hairline, were five deep, fresh scratches. They were identical to the ones Daniel had seen on the front door. And they were oozing that same black, oily resin.

Daniel’s grip on Asher’s waist tightened, but he didn't pull away. Terror, cold and sharp, pierced through his relief.

"Dan?" Asher asked, turning his head slightly. "You're squeezing a bit hard, honey."

"Sorry," Daniel whispered, his mind racing. He looked at the others. Ethan had seen it too. Lucian was backing toward the door. Ed was shaking his head, tears streaming down his face.

"I’m just... I’m just so happy you’re okay," Daniel lied, his voice thick with a new kind of dread. He realized then that the loop hadn't just brought them back to the house. It had brought back a version of their lives that the house wanted them to see.

And whatever was wearing Asher’s skin wasn't done playing.

"Let's eat," the thing that looked like Asher said, sliding a plate of golden pancakes onto the table. "We have all the time in the world. We’re never going to have to leave."

The "Asher" looked directly at Daniel, and for the first time, Daniel noticed that the reflection in Asher's glasses didn't show the kitchen. It showed the four figures standing in the road, their eyes missing, waiting in the dark.

"Right, Dan?" Asher asked, his voice now a perfect mimicry of Daniel’s own. "We're never leaving."

Outside, the sun suddenly vanished, plunged into a premature and total eclipse. The music on the radio began to slow down, the singer's voice deepening into a distorted, demonic growl.

"Eat your breakfast, Daniel," the house seemed to whisper through the walls. "The master is watching."

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***