CHAPTER 4: MAEVE

The first official day of classes felt like slipping back into a well-worn, comforting rhythm. I moved through the early morning campus crowds with my canvas bag slung over my shoulder, my dark brown hair tucked behind one ear, nodding at familiar faces but never stopping to chat. English Literature seminar at nine, Creative Writing workshop at eleven, and a brisk meeting with my advisor in between to finalize the structural components of the internship application packet. This was the life I had built over two grueling years—quiet, purposeful, structured, and entirely mine.

​I spent most of the morning taking meticulous notes in the back row of my lectures, already outlining my personal essay for the Aldridge Literary Review. The prompt asked for a singular, shaping moment that defined my relationship with storytelling. I kept circling around safe, sterile answers—my grandmother’s old library, a high school analysis of Gothic prose—carefully avoiding anything that felt too raw, too personal, or too exposing.

​By early afternoon, I was mentally exhausted but quietly satisfied. This version of me—focused, private, completely in control—had taken two years of absolute discipline to construct. I wasn’t about to let anything crack the varnish now.

​I was walking toward the stone fountain near the student union when I saw him.

​Jordan Hayes stood by the edge of the water, the hands of one long arm buried in the pockets of his crisp chinos. He looked effortlessly put-together in a white button-down with the sleeves rolled up to his forearms, his dark brown hair neatly styled, his warm hazel eyes scanning the passing crowd. The exact moment his gaze spotted me, his face broke into that genuine, steady smile that always made the tight coil in my chest loosen.

​I hadn’t been expecting him. He’d mentioned he might only be on campus for half the day because of his pre-law orientation seminars and cohort meetings, but seeing him here—solid, reliable, and beautifully uncomplicated—hit me harder than I anticipated after the silent chaos of yesterday.

​“Jordan!” I called out, my pace quickening across the brick quad.

​He opened his arms just as I reached him. I ran straight into his space, wrapping my arms around his neck. He laughed softly, lifting my feet off the pavement for a brief moment in that easy, athletic way of his. When my boots touched the ground again, I rose onto my toes and kissed him. It was warm, familiar, and steady—the kind of kiss that reminded me exactly why I had chosen this route. Why I had chosen him.

​“I thought you might not make it onto the main campus today,” I said, my fingers still hooked into the fabric of his shirt.

​“Managed to slip out of the administrative brief early,” he said, brushing a stray strand of hair from my forehead. His hazel eyes were remarkably soft. “Couldn’t miss seeing my favorite junior on her first official day back. You look good, Maeve. How’s the new apartment treating you?”

​“It’s… fine,” I said quickly, the words rolling out perhaps a fraction too fast. “Jess is really nice. The bedroom has great light.”

​I didn’t mention Nate. Not even a passing syllable. The words felt physically lodged somewhere behind my ribs, far too heavy, sharp, and complicated for a beautiful afternoon. Jordan was my safe space, my clean harbor. I wanted to keep him entirely separate from the wreckage.

​He took my hand naturally, threading his fingers through mine. “Come on. I’ve got about an hour before my next mock trial meeting. Let me buy you coffee.”

​“Yes, please.”

​We walked to the small café just off the main quad, the one with the outdoor seating shaded by ancient maples and decent espresso. Jordan ordered my usual without asking—an oat milk latte with an extra shot—and paid before I could even think to reach for my wallet. We found a small iron table in the deep shade, and for the next forty minutes, everything felt incredibly simple.

​He told me about his pre-law cohort and the competitive structure of the new mock trial team he was considering joining. I told him about my internship packet and the stack of dense books I’d already assigned myself for the semester. He listened the way he always did—fully, attentively, asking quiet, perceptive questions that proved he actually cared about the details. There were no games with Jordan. No sharp edges. Just a steady, unblinking warmth.

​Being with him felt like surfacing after holding my breath underwater for too long. After the suffocating tension of last night—the surgical way Nate and I had cut into each other across the kitchen counter—I desperately needed this. Someone who didn't come with a buried archive of history or charged, industrial silences. Someone whose sheer presence didn't make the molecular air feel electric and dangerous.

​When it was finally time for him to leave, he walked me partway back toward my off-campus block, kissed me again under the shadow of the brick arches, and squeezed my fingers.

​“Text me later tonight?” he asked, his smile trustworthy and good. “Let me know how the rest of your readings go.”

​“I will. Thank you for this, Jordan. I really needed it today.”

​“Anytime, Maeve.”

​I watched him walk away for a moment, his shoulders relaxed and confident, before I turned back toward home. The lingering sense of relief settled over me like a soft blanket. This was exactly what I wanted. This was the sanity I had chosen.

​That fragile feeling lasted until the exact second I opened the apartment door.

​Nate was already there.

​He sat at the small kitchen table, a plastic takeout container open in front of him, slowly scrolling through something on his phone. The faded Aldridge hoodie from the night before was gone, replaced by a black mesh practice shirt that stretched tightly across his broad shoulders and the lean, functional muscle of his chest. His dark hair looked slightly damp at the ends, like he’d recently showered after a grueling afternoon on the court. He didn't look up immediately when the deadbolt turned, but I knew he registered my presence the second my boot hit the linoleum.

​Jess wasn’t home yet.

​I closed the heavy door behind me with a soft, deliberate click and headed straight for my bedroom without speaking a single word. I changed out of my campus clothes, pulling on an oversized sweater and simple leggings, before returning to the kitchen to heat up yesterday's leftovers.

​The silence in the room was loud. Heavy. Pointed.

​Nate kept eating, his silver-blue eyes fixed firmly on his phone screen. I stood at the polar opposite end of the small kitchen, leaning my weight against the counter as I waited for the microwave timer to count down. The physical space between us felt deliberately measured, like an invisible, high-voltage line neither of us was willing to cross.

​The microwave beeped sharply. I pulled my container out, grabbed a fork, and carried it to the far end of the small kitchen table. I sat as far from him as humanly possible without moving entirely into the living room.

​We ate in complete, absolute silence. No eye contact. No acknowledgment. Just the occasional, rhythmic scrape of plastic against plastic and the distant, muffled hum of campus life floating through the glass of the window.

​But I could feel his presence like pure static electricity on my skin. He was the kind of person who took up the entirety of a room without even trying, his massive frame anchoring the small kitchen. A faint, clean scent of his body wash—something masculine, crisp, and cold—drifted across the table, irritating me for no rational reason whatsoever. Every single bite of my food tasted more mechanical than the last.

​This was supposed to be my apartment. My fresh start. My territory. Instead, I was eating dinner like a wary animal sharing a cage with something dangerous and unpredictable.

​Nate finished his meal first. He stood up, his massive shadow falling across my plate for a fraction of a second, and tossed his empty container into the trash before rinsing his fork thoroughly in the sink. For a horrifying second, I thought he might actually say something. Break the silence. Push against my boundaries the way he had last night.

​He didn't.

​He simply dried his hands on a paper towel, turned on his heel, and walked toward the couch. He dropped his heavy frame onto the cushions and pulled out his laptop, completely acting as if I weren't even in the room.

​I stayed at the kitchen table much longer than necessary, staring down at my half-eaten food. The profound relief I’d felt with Jordan by the fountain had evaporated somewhere between the front door and this linoleum floor. In its place was the familiar, tight, suffocating coil in my chest—the one I’d spent two years learning to manage through sheer force of will.

​I finally stood up, cleaned up my own mess with quiet, efficient movements, and retreated directly to my bedroom without a word.

​As I closed the door, I leaned my weight against the wood, my eyes snapping shut in the dim light of my room.

​One day down.

​How many more until he was finally gone?

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***