The first study session

The next afternoon.

Elena stood outside the Bennett mansion.

Her jaw dropped.

Elena: Is this a house or a shopping mall?

She checked the address again.

Same location.

Same number.

Same mansion.

She swallowed.

Then rang the bell.

A servant opened the door.

A few moments later—

Daniel appeared.

Daniel: Right on time.

Elena: You forgot to mention your family owns half the city.

Daniel laughed.

Daniel: Come in.

SCENE SWITCH TO —

Noah's room.

The door opened.

Daniel: Noah.

No response.

Daniel: Noah.

Still nothing.

Daniel looked around.

Empty.

Then noticed the open window.

Daniel: You've got to be kidding me.

THE BACKYARD -

Jonathan.

Mike.

And Noah.

All three sat on a garden wall.

Mike: Your tutor arrived.

Noah: That's unfortunate.

Jonathan: Try being nice.

Noah: Why?

Mike: Because normal people do that.

Noah: Sounds boring.

Jonathan laughed.

Then suddenly noticed someone approaching.

A familiar figure.

His smile slowly disappeared.

Wait.

No way.

The same woman from last night?

The one who beat up five high school boys?

Jonathan: Hold on...

Elena finally reached them.

She stopped.

Her eyes widened.

Elena: You?!

Jonathan pointed at her.

Jonathan: You're the boxing lady!

Elena: Boxing lady?!

Mike: Wait.

You two know each other?

Jonathan: Kind of.

She saved a kid from getting bullied yesterday.

Then nearly scared the bullies more than I did.

Elena: Excuse me?

I was helping.

Jonathan: You looked ready to enter a professional wrestling match.

Mike burst out laughing.

Even Noah looked mildly interested now.

Mike: Hold on.

You're telling me my friend's tutor beats up teenagers?

Elena: They deserved it.

Jonathan: Fair enough.

Elena folded her arms.

Elena: What are you even doing here?

Jonathan: I live next door.

We're family friends.

Elena blinked.

Of course.

What were the odds?

Mike: Small world.

Elena: Apparently.

Jonathan smiled.

A genuine smile.

One that was surprisingly difficult to ignore.

Before the conversation could continue—

Noah stood up.

Noah: Can everyone stop talking about yesterday?

I'd like to remind you all that I'm still the main problem here.

Everyone turned toward him.

Elena: So.

You're Noah.

Noah: Unfortunately.

Elena: I'm your tutor.

Noah: That's even more unfortunate.

Elena: Great.

He's annoying.

Noah: Great.

She's annoying.

Mike: Oh this is gonna be fun.

Jonathan: We're doomed.

Noah and Elena glared at each other.

And for some reason—

Neither looked away first.

The Bennett backyard remained lively.

Mike was still trying not to laugh over the "boxing lady" incident.

Meanwhile, Elena folded her arms.

Still annoyed.

Still questioning why she accepted this job.

Mike: Wait.

One question.

How did you even get into this place?

Elena: Through the front gate?

Mike: No, I mean who let you in?

Elena: Daniel.

He brought me here and left a few minutes ago.

Jonathan: Sounds about right.

Mike: Yeah.

He's probably working again.

Noah rolled his eyes.

Noah: Shocking.

The workaholic is working.

For a brief moment, the conversation became quieter.

Surprisingly...

It wasn't awkward.

At least not between Jonathan and Elena.

Jonathan: So.

Did you get home safely yesterday?

Elena looked at him.

The question caught her off guard.

Nobody had asked that.

Not really.

Elena: I did.

Eventually.

Jonathan: Good.

I was worried.

A small silence followed.

Mike immediately looked between them.

Then at Noah.

Then back at them.

His grin grew wider.

Dangerously wider.

Mike: Aww.

That's sweet.

Jonathan: Shut up.

Mike: I'm just saying—

Jonathan: Mike.

Mike: Fine.

I'm quiet.

He wasn't quiet.

Not even close.

Jonathan: Ignore him.

He's impossible.

Elena: Funny.

I was about to say the same thing about someone else.

She glanced toward Noah.

Noah looked offended.

Noah: Wow.

I've known you for ten minutes.

And you're already attacking me.

Elena: Consider it a professional assessment.

Jonathan laughed.

A genuine laugh.

The kind that felt warm.

Comfortable.

Easy.

For a second, Elena found herself smiling too.

Mike immediately noticed.

Of course he did.

Mike: Interesting.

Very interesting.

Jonathan: Stop making that face.

Mike: What face?

Jonathan: That face.

Mike: I don't know what you're talking about.

He absolutely knew.

Meanwhile Noah sat quietly watching.

Not jealous.

Not interested.

Just...

Observing.

Elena laughed differently around Jonathan.

More naturally.

Jonathan seemed calmer around Elena too.

Weird.

Noah couldn't explain why he noticed.

Or why he cared enough to notice.

Eventually Jonathan checked his watch.

Jonathan: We should go.

My mom's going to kill me if I'm late again.

Mike: Same.

And unlike Noah, I enjoy being alive.

Noah: Fair.

Jonathan stood up.

Before leaving, he looked toward Elena.

Jonathan: Good luck.

You'll need it.

Elena: That's reassuring.

Jonathan: Trust me.

I'm trying to help.

Elena laughed.

Then Jonathan and Mike left.

The backyard suddenly felt quieter.

Far quieter.

And then there were two.

Elena.

And Noah.

SCENE SWITCH TO —

Noah's room.

Elena stepped inside.

And immediately froze.

This wasn't what she expected.

The room wasn't messy.

Wasn't chaotic.

Wasn't covered in video games.

Instead—

Books.

Lots of books.

History.

Economics.

Science.

Literature.

Philosophy.

An entire shelf filled with them.

Elena frowned.

Something didn't add up.

Elena: I thought you hated studying.

Noah: I do.

Elena: Then why do you own enough books to start a library?

Noah: They look pretty.

Elena: You're a terrible liar.

For the first time—

Noah smiled.

A real smile.

Brief.

But real.

Elena sat down across from him.

Pulled out her notes.

Opened her laptop.

Prepared for battle.

Elena: Alright.

Let's see where we're starting from.

Show me your recent test papers.

Noah: Why?

Elena: Because I'm your tutor.

Noah: That's not a real answer.

Elena: Because I need to know how much damage we're dealing with.

Noah sighed dramatically.

Then handed over the papers.

Elena began reading.

One minute passed.

Then two.

Then three.

Her expression slowly changed.

Confusion.

Then disbelief.

Then suspicion.

Every wrong answer looked...

Intentional.

Painfully intentional.

As if somebody had gone out of their way to choose the second-best answer every single time.

Impossible.

Nobody accidentally performed this consistently.

She looked up.

Elena: Did you do this on purpose?

Noah: Do what?

Elena: Fail.

A silence followed.

For the first time all afternoon—

The playful version of Noah disappeared.

Completely.

His eyes met hers.

And suddenly he seemed older.

More tired.

More serious.

Noah: What if I did?

The room became quiet.

Outside, birds chirped.

Somewhere downstairs, a door closed.

But inside the room—

Nothing moved.

Elena: Then I'd ask why.

Noah: And if I don't want to answer?

Elena: Then I'll figure it out myself.

Something flickered across Noah's face.

Amusement.

Curiosity.

Maybe even challenge.

Nobody had ever said that before.

Most people lectured him.

Judged him.

Compared him.

But this girl?

She looked at him like a puzzle.

And somehow—

That irritated him.

Noah: You're very confident.

Elena: Comes with being right most of the time.

Noah: That's annoying.

Elena: I get that a lot.

A tiny smile escaped him.

Against his will.

And for the first time since entering the Bennett mansion—

Elena felt it.

Something wasn't right.

Not with the house.

Not with the grades.

Not with Noah.

Everyone around him kept describing him as lazy.

Irresponsible.

A disappointment.

But sitting across from her now—

He didn't look like any of those things.

He looked like someone hiding something.

And Elena had a feeling that whatever it was...

It was far more complicated than bad grades.

The room remained silent.

Noah leaned back in his chair.

Elena continued staring at the test papers spread across the desk.

The more she looked at them, the more ridiculous they seemed.

Wrong answers.

Everywhere.

But not random ones.

Calculated ones.

Carefully chosen mistakes.

As if someone had intentionally avoided getting the correct answer.

Finally, she put the papers down.

Elena: You're not failing because you can't study.

Noah: That's your conclusion?

Elena: You're failing because you want to.

A small smile appeared on Noah's face.

Noah: Congratulations.

You're the first tutor to figure that out.

Elena: How many tutors have there been?

Noah: Five.

Elena: Including me?

Noah: Including you.

Elena rubbed her temples.

Elena: Your brother wasn't kidding.

Noah: Daniel talks too much.

Elena: Daniel seems concerned about you.

Noah: That's his hobby.

The answer came too quickly.

Too casually.

Like something rehearsed.

Elena noticed.

But didn't push.

Not yet.

She opened one of the textbooks.

Elena: Fine.

Let's start with economics.

Noah: I'd rather jump off the roof.

Elena: That's unfortunate because we're studying economics.

Noah: You're cruel.

Elena: I've been told that before.

For the next twenty minutes, Noah tried everything.

Absolutely everything.

He yawned dramatically.

Complained.

Made terrible jokes.

Asked unrelated questions.

Dropped his pen.

Dropped it again.

Then somehow dropped it a third time.

Elena: Are you done?

Noah: With studying?

Yes.

Elena: With being annoying.

Noah: Never.

Elena sighed.

Deeply.

Thirty minutes later—

Something strange happened.

Noah accidentally solved a difficult question.

In less than a minute.

Without notes.

Without help.

Without hesitation.

Elena blinked.

Elena: Do that again.

Noah: What?

Elena: The question.

Noah shrugged.

Then solved another one.

Correctly.

Again.

Elena slowly lowered her pen.

Elena: You're kidding.

Noah: About what?

Elena: You're smarter than half the students in my college.

Noah: That's depressing for your college.

Elena: Noah.

I'm serious.

For the first time—

The joking stopped.

Elena: Why are you pretending to be bad at this?

Noah looked away.

Toward the window.

Toward the evening sky.

Anywhere but her.

Noah: Because when you're expected to be perfect...

Failure becomes surprisingly relaxing.

The words slipped out before he could stop them.

A mistake.

A rare one.

Silence.

Elena stared at him.

Something about the sentence felt heavier than it should have.

Not like a joke.

Not like sarcasm.

Something real.

But before she could ask more—

Noah stood up.

Noah: Break time.

Elena: We don't have break time.

Noah: We do now.

He disappeared from the room.

A few minutes later he returned carrying two cold drinks.

He placed one on the desk.

In front of her.

Elena: Bribery?

Noah: Peace offering.

Elena: For what?

Noah: Existing.

Despite herself—

Elena laughed.

And Noah noticed.

Immediately.

Interesting.

That was the first genuine laugh he'd heard from her.

Not a sarcastic one.

Not an irritated one.

A real one.

The realization surprised both of them.

For the remainder of the lesson, things became easier.

Not friendly.

Not exactly.

But less hostile.

They argued over formulas.

Debated answers.

Corrected each other.

Occasionally insulted each other's intelligence.

Professionally.

And somehow—

The two hours passed surprisingly fast.

6:03 PM.

The session was over.

Elena packed her notes into her bag.

Elena: Same time on Wednesday.

Noah: Tragic.

Elena: You'll survive.

Noah: Debatable.

She rolled her eyes.

Then headed toward the door.

Noah: Elena.

She stopped.

Turned around.

For a brief second—

He looked like he wanted to say something.

Something important.

But then the usual smirk returned.

Noah: Don't be late next time.

Elena stared at him.

Completely unimpressed.

Elena: You're impossible.

Noah: See you Wednesday.

As she walked down the hallway, she couldn't stop thinking about him.

Not because she liked him.

Absolutely not.

Because he didn't make sense.

Nothing about Noah Bennett made sense.

And upstairs—

Noah watched her leave from his bedroom window.

For the first time in months—

The house felt slightly less boring.

Neither realized it.

But the first crack in both of their walls had already appeared.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***