Choosing us

For months, everything between them was perfect—safe, passionate, entirely theirs. But there was one shadow hanging over their happiness, one thing Eliot had been dreading and putting off for as long as possible: telling his parents.

His parents were kind, loving people, but they were also traditional, old-fashioned, the kind of people who had always imagined their quiet, studious son would grow up, marry a nice girl, settle down nearby, and give them grandchildren. They knew Silas, of course—knew him as Eliot’s best friend, the boy who had always looked out for him, who was practically family. But they had no idea things had changed. No idea that their son was in love with him.

Eliot put it off again and again, too scared, too nervous, too used to pleasing everyone around him. But Silas, though he never pressured him, always knew. He would hold Eliot at night, pressing soft kisses to his hair, and whisper, “Whenever you’re ready, baby. I’ll be right there with you. Whatever happens, we face it together.”

Finally, one Sunday afternoon, Eliot gathered all his courage. He invited his parents over to their apartment, his hands shaking so hard he could barely pour the tea, his heart hammering so loud he was sure everyone in the room could hear it. Silas stood right beside him the whole time, big and steady, his hand resting warm and firm on the small of Eliot’s back, grounding him, letting him know he wasn’t alone.

It went exactly as Eliot had feared.

As soon as the words left his mouth—“Mom, Dad… Silas and I are together. We’re in love. We’re a couple.”—the room went deadly quiet.

His mother’s face drained of all color. His father stared at him, his mouth falling open in shock, then quickly twisting into disapproval.

“What? What do you mean, together?” his father asked, his voice sharp and disbelieving. “Eliot… you’re straight. You’ve always liked girls. This… this is ridiculous. This is just some phase, isn’t it? Some confusion because you spend so much time together—”

“It’s not a phase,” Eliot said, his voice trembling but surprisingly firm. “It’s real. I love him. I love Silas more than anything in the world.”

“But he’s a man!” his mother cried, her eyes filling with tears, looking between them like she was heartbroken and horrified all at once. “He’s your best friend! This is wrong, Eliot. It’s unnatural. People will talk. People will judge you. We raised you better than this—”

“Better than what?” Silas cut in, his voice low and calm but with an edge of warning, stepping a little closer to Eliot, pulling him slightly back against his chest, protective as always. “Better than being loved completely, faithfully, more fiercely than you could ever imagine? I love your son. I would die before I let anything hurt him. How is that wrong?”

His father turned on him, angry now. “You! This is your fault, isn’t it? You confused him! You took advantage of him, of how trusting and sweet he is—you twisted his head—”

“Stop it!” Eliot shouted.

The room went silent again. Everyone stared at him, shocked—Eliot almost never raised his voice. He was always the quiet one, the polite one, the one who agreed just to keep the peace. But right now, his face was flushed, his eyes bright and fierce, his hands clenched into fists at his sides.

“Don’t you dare talk to him like that,” Eliot said, his voice shaking with anger and passion. “Don’t you dare blame Silas. This is my choice. I love him. I fell in love with him. He didn’t force me. He didn’t trick me. He loves me. He takes care of me. He makes me happier than I have ever been in my whole life. And you… you’re supposed to love me. You’re supposed to want me to be happy. But you don’t even care, do you? You just care about what people will say. You care about what you think is ‘right’ instead of caring about me.”

“Eliot, please, listen to reason—” his mother started, reaching out for him, but Eliot stepped back, shaking his head.

“No. I’ve listened to reason my whole life. I’ve done everything everyone ever told me to do. I was the good son. The good student. The nice boy who never caused any trouble. But this is the one thing I am not backing down from. This is the one thing I will never apologize for. I am with Silas. I am staying with Silas. If you can’t accept that… if you can’t accept him, or me like this… then I guess you don’t have to be part of our lives anymore.”

The words hung heavy in the air, sharp and final. His parents stared at him, stunned, never having seen this side of him—stubborn, brave, unshakeable.

Silas stood behind him, his heart swelling with so much pride and love it almost hurt. He reached down, wrapping his arms tight around Eliot’s waist, pressing a soft, proud kiss to the side of his neck, right there in front of everyone.

“He means it,” Silas said, his voice steady and sure. “He chose me. And I will spend the rest of my life proving to him that he made the right choice.”

His parents left that day upset, tearful, angry, refusing to understand. For weeks after, there was silence from their end, and Eliot ached a little, missing them, hurting that they couldn’t love him enough to accept him. But he never wavered. He never regretted what he said. Every time doubt crept in, every time he felt sad, he would look at Silas—at the man who loved him so fiercely, who protected him, who cherished him—and he knew, absolutely, that he had made the right choice.

And slowly, very slowly, things got better. His parents started calling again. At first it was stiff, awkward, no mention of Silas or their relationship. But eventually, they asked about him. Eventually, they agreed to meet them for dinner. It wasn’t perfect. It took time, years even, for them to truly understand and fully accept. But they came around, little by little, seeing what Eliot had known all along: that Silas loved their son more than anything, and that Eliot was happy—truly, deeply happy—in a way he never had been before.

But even if they hadn’t? Even if they had never spoken to him again? Eliot would have chosen Silas every single time.

That night, after that first difficult meeting with his parents, after they had left and the apartment was quiet again, Eliot collapsed into Silas’ arms, shaking a little from the adrenaline and emotion of standing up for himself.

Silas held him tight, carrying him straight to their bedroom, laying him down gently on the bed before crawling over him, caging him in with his body. He looked down at Eliot, his dark eyes shining with overwhelming pride and love, soft and warm in a way only Eliot ever got to see.

“You were incredible today,” Silas whispered, leaning down to kiss him, slow and sweet and reverent. “So brave. So strong. My beautiful, perfect boy. You stood up for us. You chose us. I love you so much I could scream.”

Eliot smiled, wrapping his arms around Silas’ neck, pulling him closer. “Of course I did. You’re worth fighting for. You’re worth everything.”

Silas groaned low in his throat, kissing him again, deeper this time, hungrier, his hands starting to wander over Eliot’s body, warm and possessive. The tension and emotion of the day melted away, replaced quickly by the familiar, burning desire that always existed between them.

“I need you,” Silas murmured against his skin, dragging his lips down Eliot’s throat, biting gently at the soft skin, claiming him all over again. “I need to show you how proud I am of you. How much I love you. Let me worship you, baby. Let me make you feel how much you mean to me.”

It was slow and sweet that night, tender and passionate, different from the rough, claiming sex Silas used when he was jealous or angry. This was love—pure, overwhelming, devoted love. Silas undressed him slowly, kissing every inch of skin, whispering endless praise against his body, telling him how amazing he was, how proud he was of him, how much he was loved and cherished.

He took his time stretching him, preparing him, touching him exactly how he knew he loved, making Eliot writhe and whimper beneath him, completely undone by the intensity of his affection. When he finally pushed inside him, it was slow and deep, pressing his chest tight against Eliot’s, resting his forehead against Eliot’s, looking straight into his eyes the whole time.

“You are mine,” Silas whispered, thrusting slowly, deeply, making sure every movement was filled with love. “My brave boy. My everything. I love you. I love you. I love you.”

Eliot cried happy tears as they moved together, completely surrounded by Silas’ warmth, his strength, his love. It was perfect. It was everything. They came together, crying out each other’s names, holding each other so tight it felt like they were merging into one person, bound together completely by love and trust and choice.

They lay tangled together for hours after, kissing, talking, holding each other, safe and happy in their own little world.

The morning sun was streaming through the curtains, painting the room in soft gold, when Eliot woke up. He was warm, comfortable, completely wrapped up in Silas’ big arms, his back pressed tight against Silas’ chest, their legs tangled together. He stretched slowly, smiling at the familiar weight and heat of the man he loved more than anything.

Then he felt it.

Silas shifted behind him, reaching over to the bedside table, retrieving two small velvet boxes he had hidden there. Eliot turned in his arms, curious, blinking sleepily up at him.

Silas was smiling—soft, nervous, happier than Eliot had ever seen him. He sat up a little, pulling Eliot up with him, until they were sitting face to face in the messy, rumpled bed, sheets pooled around their waists.

“I was going to wait longer,” Silas admitted, his voice soft and rough with sleep. “But after yesterday… after seeing you fight for us, choose us, love me so fiercely… I couldn’t wait anymore. I need you to know, officially, forever, exactly where you belong.”

He opened the first box. Inside sat a beautiful, simple silver ring, polished and shining. He took it out, reaching for Eliot’s left hand, his fingers brushing softly against Eliot’s skin.

“Eliot Hayes,” Silas said, his voice serious, sincere, filled with love. “You are my best friend. You are the love of my life. You are my everything. I have loved you for years, and I will love you for every year to come. Will you wear this ring? Will you be mine, officially, legally, completely, for the rest of our lives?”

Eliot’s eyes filled with happy tears, his lip trembling as he nodded frantically. “Yes. Yes, a thousand times yes. Of course I will.”

Silas smiled, bright and brilliant, and slid the ring onto Eliot’s finger. It fit perfectly, warm and solid, a perfect circle—forever, unending, exactly like their love.

Then Eliot reached for the second box, the one Silas had left open on the sheets. He took out the matching ring—thicker, sturdier, but the same simple shining silver. He reached for Silas’ big, rough hand, his fingers shaking a little with emotion as he lifted it.

“Silas Hale,” Eliot whispered, looking up at him with all the love in the world shining in his eyes. “You saved me. You loved me. You taught me how to be brave, how to love, how to be happy. You are my whole world. I choose you. I will always choose you. I love you. Forever.”

He slid the ring onto Silas’ finger, watching it settle there, looking right where it belonged. Silas lifted his hand, admiring the ring, then tangled his fingers with Eliot’s, holding their hands up together, watching the sunlight catch on the matching silver bands.

“Forever,” Silas murmured, leaning down to kiss him, soft and sweet, sealing the promise. “You and me. Against the whole world. Forever.”

And as they sat there, wrapped in each other’s arms, wearing the rings that bound them together completely, they both knew it was true.

It had been a long, hard road. It had been secret, forbidden, messy, and complicated. It had been dark and obsessive and intense in every way. But it was theirs. And it was perfect.

They had everything they ever wanted. They had each other. And that was more than enough.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***