Just a girl from the app

My phone died at 11:42 PM. That part was true.

The rest? That’s where it gets messy.

My name’s Jay. Jay Miller, if you’re the front desk at The Meridian. Just Jay, if you’re Maya. _Babe_, if you’re Kiki. And _asshole_, if you’re being honest. Which I wasn’t. Not for three years.

Let me tell you how it starts. Not with Maya. Not with Kiki. With me.

I’m good at beginnings. First dates, first kisses, first _I’ve never told anyone this before_. I’m good at the part where you lean in, where your eyes get soft, where you think _this one’s different_. I’m good at typing. _Jay is typing…_ That’s my brand. Promise in progress.

Kiki was first. Or, she was the one who stayed. Bar. Vodka soda. _Honest eyes_. She had them. She also had a lease that needed a second name and a laugh that made my chest feel less empty. We got Bear a year in. I told her a dog would make it real. What I meant was: a dog would make it harder for her to leave.

Then there was Maya. The app. 9 PM on a Tuesday when Kiki was at her sister’s and the apartment was too quiet. I wasn’t looking for anything. That’s what I tell myself. I was just… bored. Lonely. Whatever word makes it sound less like a choice.

Maya didn’t play games. No “hey.” No mirror selfies. She sent me a song. _Listen to this when you drive at night_. I did. Then I sent one back. Then it was 2 AM and I was telling her my dad left when I was seven. Real shit. The kind I hadn’t told Kiki in months because with Kiki, we were past confessions. We were in the _did you take out the trash_ phase.

With Maya, I was new again.

_Fate > algorithms_. I wrote that. I meant it, in the moment. I mean a lot of things in the moment.

The first time I lied to Maya, it was small. _Still at work_. I was at home, Kiki asleep next to me, Bear snoring at our feet. I just didn’t want the conversation to end. With Kiki, silence was comfortable. With Maya, silence felt like losing.

The first time I lied to Kiki, it was bigger. _Who’s Maya?_ she asked, holding my phone. I’d fallen asleep. Rookie mistake. _Just a girl from the app. Not serious. You know I delete those eventually._

I didn’t delete Maya.

I kept both. That’s the juicy part, right? The depravity. I had Kiki to come home to — dinner, Netflix, the dog, the fight about who left the light on. Stability. And I had Maya in my pocket — new, hungry, _You make me feel seen_. Dopamine.

I told myself I’d choose. After this trip. After Kiki’s birthday. After Maya stopped asking _when can I meet your friends?_ I got good at _Jay is typing…_ and then deleting. Good at leaving things half-said so I could live in the maybe.

Then Snapmap. Fucking Snapmap.

I was at The Meridian. Not with Kiki. With Tasha. Yeah, there’s a third. Did you think I’d stop at two? Tasha was _no strings_. A “work client.” She knew about Kiki. She didn’t know about Maya. I told Tasha I was in an open relationship. I told Kiki I was working late. I told Maya my phone died.

Three truths. Zero true.

When Maya texted _Then why does your snapmap say you’re at Kiki’s?_, I panicked. _That’s my cousin’s place. Phone died so I borrowed hers._ I watched the _delivered_ turn to _read_. I watched _Maya is typing…_ and felt sick. Because Maya wasn’t like the others. Maya asked questions and waited for answers.

Then she sent the screenshot.

Tasha was in the bathroom. I stared at the photo — me, drunk, arm around Tasha, Tasha’s hand on my chest. Kiki’s story. I hadn’t even known Kiki was there that night. Or maybe I did. Maybe I wanted to get caught.

_Maya wait. That’s not what it looks like._

God, I hated myself as I typed it. Because it was _exactly_ what it looked like.

_Then what does a lie look like, Jay?_

I deleted my reply. Not because I was smart. Because I was a coward. _Jay unsent a message_. The most honest thing I’d done in months.

_I love you._ I sent that at 12:17 AM. To Maya. While Tasha was in the shower and Kiki was asleep with my dog. I sent it because it was true and because it wasn’t and because I wanted someone, anyone, to say it back before it all collapsed.

_You loved the idea of me._

She left the chat. And it felt like the floor gave out.

I thought that was rock bottom. Then the hotel door opened at 3 PM the next day.

Maya. In person. Real. Angry. Beautiful in a way that made me want to confess everything and also run. _Kiki says hi._

Two words. My whole life split open.

_Babe? Who is it?_ Tasha, from the bed.

Maya’s face. I’ll never forget it. Not the anger. The _clarity_. Like she finally saw me. All of me. The guy who types _fate > algorithms_ while two other women think he’s theirs.

She left. I stood there in the hallway, towel around my neck, dick gone soft, life gone sideways. I went back inside. Tasha was already dressing. _Who was that?_ _No one_, I said. The last lie I told that day.

I drove home. Kiki wasn’t there. Bear was. The locks were changed. My key didn’t work. I stood on my own porch like a stranger.

My phone lit up. Kiki. _We’re not yours anymore._

Then Maya. A screenshot of my text to Kiki: _Where are you? Bear’s alone. I’m coming home._ Maya had sent it with one word: _Coward._

I sat on the curb. Opened the app. The one where I met Maya.

_0 new matches._

For the first time in three years, no one was typing.

And I had no one left to lie to but myself.

---

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***