The first move

Adrian Vale woke at exactly six in the morning without the help of an alarm, as he had every day for the past seven years. His routine never changed—stretching, brewing coffee, reading for a few quiet minutes, then observing both himself and the world around him. To Adrian, routine was more than discipline; it was a diagnostic instrument. The smallest disruption often revealed that something inside a person had shifted long before they noticed it themselves. Even after receiving two anonymous messages connected to Emily’s case, his pulse remained steady and his breathing calm. That composure wasn’t natural—it had been forged through years of training. Standing on his apartment balcony with a mug of coffee, he watched the city awaken beneath him. Office workers hurried through intersections, cyclists weaved through traffic, vendors prepared their stalls, and strangers passed one another without a second glance. Adrian wondered how many people unknowingly crossed paths with killers every single day. Society expected evil to wear a frightening face, but experience had taught him the opposite. The most dangerous people often smiled first.

Inside his apartment, one entire wall was covered with whiteboards filled with symbols, dates, geometric shapes, and colored threads connecting seemingly unrelated points. There were no photographs or names—only a psychological landscape that only Adrian could understand. His eyes stopped on a sentence written across one corner: Find the killer. After a brief pause, he erased it and replaced it with new words: Make the killer reveal himself. The distinction mattered. Investigators chased criminals, but psychologists understood that people eventually exposed themselves if placed in the right environment. Rather than hunt his enemy, Adrian intended to build the perfect psychological trap and patiently wait for the truth to walk into it.

Before beginning his online therapy sessions, Adrian made a subtle modification to his encrypted platform. Every new patient would now receive a different opening question, each carefully designed to provoke a unique pattern of responses rather than collect information. He wasn’t interested in questionnaires that people could manipulate. Conversations forced improvisation, and improvisation revealed character. From a single exchange, Adrian could estimate impulsiveness, empathy, narcissism, deception habits, fear responses, and long-term planning ability. Throughout the evening, patient after patient entered the virtual sessions. Some confessed guilt, others shared delusions or grief, and most behaved exactly as expected—until one username appeared on the screen: AshesRemain.

The conversation began with a single question: Do you believe every question deserves an answer? Adrian replied that some questions existed only to measure the person answering them. The stranger immediately recognized the game and admitted they were measuring each other instead. Their exchange remained strangely calm, free of threats or emotional bait. When Adrian asked why he had been chosen, the answer unsettled him more than he cared to admit. Because you’re difficult to manipulate. Most people crave attention. You crave understanding. The statement was painfully accurate. Adrian finally asked what the stranger wanted, and the reply arrived without hesitation: To know whether revenge heals people… or merely changes the kind of monster they become. Before Adrian could respond, the session disconnected, leaving only silence behind.

Rather than dwelling on the words themselves, Adrian replayed the conversation repeatedly, studying pauses, typing rhythms, punctuation, and response times. The stranger answered philosophical questions instantly but hesitated whenever the discussion approached anything personal. That pattern suggested hidden memories rather than invented beliefs. In his notebook, Adrian summarized his conclusions in only a few words: Educated. Patient. Emotionally regulated. Never answers the real question. Near midnight, he left his apartment and wandered through the quiet city, where empty streets often sharpened his thinking. On an old riverside bridge, he crossed paths with a man in a gray coat staring into the water. Without turning around, the stranger remarked that it would rain tomorrow. Adrian answered that the forecast predicted sunshine. The forecast lies, the man said. So do people, Adrian replied. The stranger smiled faintly, whispered, You noticed, and continued walking.

Adrian deliberately counted to five before looking back. The bridge was empty. No footsteps echoed, no gates opened, and no vehicles had passed. Once home, he searched publicly available traffic cameras, weather feeds, and parking-lot livestreams. The mysterious man appeared in only a single frame before disappearing behind a passing bus. Beyond that moment, he vanished completely. The following afternoon, another anonymous therapy request appeared under the name GlassMirror. A calm male voice described recurring dreams about someone who spent years preparing revenge, only to discover after succeeding that everything had been based on a misunderstanding. When Adrian asked why he was hearing this story, the caller laughed softly and answered, Because dreams sometimes arrive before reality, before disconnecting. For the first time in years, Adrian found himself frowning.

Seeking clarity, Adrian visited the public library to return a book he had borrowed exactly six months earlier. The librarian smiled at his punctuality before suddenly becoming confused. According to the library’s records, the very same book had already been returned the previous day using Adrian’s membership card while he had been home. The book had never left his apartment. Someone hadn’t stolen his identity—they wanted him to know they could imitate it. Sitting alone on a bench outside, Adrian realized the person orchestrating these events wasn’t motivated by money or practical gain. They enjoyed demonstrating control. That night, he created a document titled Errors I Must Not Make and listed a series of rules: never assume coincidence, never underestimate patience, never react emotionally, remember every message has two audiences, and understand that every clue was intentionally placed. Finally, he added one last rule that lingered on the screen longer than the others: If someone is watching me think, change the way I think.

The next therapy session began normally until a nervous woman using the username BlueLily requested advice about her husband, claiming he had become obsessed with asking where she had been seven years earlier. Adrian questioned her carefully, only for her to calmly reveal, I don’t have a husband. The call disconnected immediately. Every trace of the account vanished moments later. The voice had been artificially altered, the IP address spoofed, and the profile created only minutes before the session. Once again, someone had transformed his own therapy platform into a channel for communicating with him. Whoever stood behind these messages wasn’t merely contacting Adrian—they were proving that every system he trusted could be entered whenever they wished.

At 2:03 in the morning, another package appeared outside Adrian’s apartment without any sign of a courier or security footage. Inside rested an exquisitely carved chessboard containing only black pieces. Attached was a handwritten note: Two players. One color. Because neither of us is innocent. Beneath the black king, Adrian discovered a hidden strip of paper carrying only three words: Your move, Doctor. He left the chessboard untouched and slowly looked toward the framed photograph of Emily resting against the wall. For seven years, he had believed he was patiently investigating a forgotten murder. Now a far more disturbing truth emerged. He was no longer the observer. Someone had been studying him long before he realized he was being watched. Somewhere beyond the screen, a patient—or perhaps something far more dangerous—waited patiently, smiling. And for the first time, Adrian considered a possibility that chilled even his disciplined mind: perhaps AshesRemain wasn’t the hunter at all. Perhaps he, too, was only another piece on someone else’s board.

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***