THE LIE WE DIDN'T SAY

The cafe smelled like coffee and rain and something else I couldn’t name.

Regret, maybe.

I was 15 minutes early. Again.

Because waiting for you had become my favorite kind of nervous. The kind that made my hands shake and my heart do stupid things when the door opened.

It was 5:00 PM on a Saturday.

Port Harcourt rain was hitting the windows in sheets. People were rushing in with wet umbrellas and loud shoes.

But I only watched the door.

5:01.

5:02.

5:03.

You walked in.

Wet hair, like you’d run from the car. White shirt, sleeves pushed up. That same tired smile you only gave me when the world had been too loud and you needed a quiet place to put it down.

*"Sorry,"* you said, sliding into the seat across from me. Droplets fell from your hair onto the table. *"Meeting ran late."*

I nodded.

Smiled.

Pretended I didn’t notice the nude lipstick on your collar.

It wasn’t red. It wasn’t pink.

It was the exact shade your sister wears. I’d seen it on her last month at the birthday party.

My stomach dropped, but I kept my face still.

*"You okay?"* I asked. Because that’s what I always asked.

*"Yeah,"* you lied. And smiled. And for half a second, I believed it.

Because wanting to believe you was stronger than the evidence on your shirt.

We talked about stupid things.

The new book you were reading. Some thriller with a twist ending.

The dog that barked at me last Tuesday when I was walking past your street.

The weather. Always the weather when we didn’t know what else to say.

*"Rain’s bad today,"* I said.

*"Yeah,"* you said. *"They said it’ll flood by the bridge."*

Normal.

Like we were normal.

But your phone buzzed under the table.

Once.

Twice.

Three times.

Four.

And four times, you didn’t check it.

You just kept stirring your coffee even though you hadn’t put sugar in it.

On the fifth buzz, you finally looked.

Pulled it out, glanced at the screen.

Your face didn’t change. But your fingers did. They tightened around the mug until your knuckles went white.

*"Work,"* you said, putting it face down fast. Too fast. *"Boring stuff. You know how it is."*

I did know how it was.

I knew boring work emails didn’t make you look like that.

I wanted to ask.

I wanted to say _Who are you texting at 5PM on a Saturday?_

I wanted to say _Why do you look like you’re being pulled apart by two different lives?_

Instead I said: *"Do you want another coffee?"*

You laughed. That soft, broken laugh you do when you’re cornered.

*"You’re good at changing the subject,"* you said.

*"You’re good at giving me reasons to,"* I answered.

Silence.

Not the comfortable kind.

The kind where both people are holding a secret in their mouths and pretending it doesn’t weigh 100 kilos.

Outside, the rain picked up. Hit the glass harder.

You watched it.

*"Do you ever think,"* you said quietly, not looking at me, *"that maybe we missed our timing?"*

My chest did something stupid.

It cracked.

*"What do you mean?"*

*"I mean,"* you said. Still watching the rain. *"Maybe we met 2 years too late. Or 2 years too early."*

You finally looked at me. *"Maybe if we’d met when we were 20 instead of 22, things would be different."*

I should’ve said _Then let’s fix the timing._

I should’ve reached across the table and taken your hand and said _I don’t care when we met, I care that we’re here now._

Instead I lied too.

Because lying was easier than bleeding.

*"Maybe,"* I said. *"But we’re here now, right? That has to count for something."*

You looked at me then. Really looked.

And for half a second I saw it.

The truth. The exhaustion. The _I don’t know how to choose and I’m scared of choosing wrong._

Before I could say anything else, your phone buzzed again.

Loud this time. On the table.

You grabbed it so fast you knocked your spoon off.

You stood up. Chair scraping loud against the tile. Everyone looked.

*"I have to go,"* you said. *"It’s urgent."*

I didn’t ask who.

You didn’t offer.

*"Is everything okay?"* I asked instead. Pathetic.

*"Yeah,"* you said. Already moving toward the door. *"Family thing."*

Family thing.

The same words you used last month.

The same words you used in January.

At the door, you paused. Turned back.

Hair wet. Shirt wet. Eyes tired.

*"Same time next week?"*

Like nothing happened. Like the lipstick. Like the buzzing. Like the lie.

*"Yeah,"* I said. My voice didn’t shake. I was proud of that. *"Same time."*

You nodded and left.

The door closed behind you and the bell jingled and then it was just me and the rain again.

I sat there.

With two coffees. One cold. One untouched.

The barista came by. *"Everything okay?"*

*"Yeah,"* I said. *"Just waiting."*

But I wasn’t waiting for you anymore.

Not really.

I was waiting for the version of you that didn’t lie.

The version that would’ve said _Stay. Let me explain._

The version that wouldn’t have a nude lipstick on their collar at 5PM on a Saturday.

I didn’t cry in the cafe.

I waited until I got home. Until I was in the shower with the water hot enough to burn.

Because the worst part wasn’t the lipstick.

It wasn’t the texts.

It wasn’t even _family emergency_.

The worst part was that moment when you said _maybe we missed our timing._

Because part of me agreed.

Part of me thought: _If we’d met earlier, before she... before whatever this is, maybe you would’ve chosen me._

And hating myself for thinking that hurt more than hating you.

I stood under the water until my fingers went wrinkled.

Until I could say it out loud to the empty bathroom:

_If this is love, why does it feel like we’re both lying to keep it alive?_

No answer came.

Just the rain. Still falling.

---

***Download NovelToon to enjoy a better reading experience!***